Just watching Keighley vs Batley, Keighley kick on the last and it hits the the ref, Leahy I believe, decision is given as a scrum to Keighley. Surely being on the last it should be a turnover, or else you'd find attacking teams trying to hit the referee on the last tackle all the time in order to gain another set? Odd.

Very odd. He was adamant that it was a correct call. Seemed very harsh on Batley. Then again he gave a joke forward pass moments later.

And now, "Knock on - Try".

WTF?

Correct decision I think

That's what I thought. I've not seen the incident but seem to remember the rule saying that if the ball hits teh ref it's a scrum with the feed to the attacking team.

Yep, that is the rule, but on the last? Seems strange.

I suppose the kicking team are still classed as attacking until the other team gathers the ball.

So therefore, kicking at the ref on a regular basis could be a reasonable idea, if you get another 6. I wonder if anyone will try it

Hopefully kicking smack into his face or personal area.

Correct call

definition of attacking team is the team with territorial advantage not possession of ball

and he didn't say knock on - try he said clock on

Its the same as off loading at the same time the ref calls held. Its an attcking scrum regardless of the tackle count.

It does seem odd that an attacking team can get a second set for just being "accurate" when kicking. Does the ref have the option of a handover if he thinks it was a deliberate action, or are his hands tied?

Thanks for that

My mate's happy. Leahy is his tutor at school.

I wouldnt think that there will be an option for refs discretion, although i'm not sure (Ganson chose to ignore a rule at Cas/Rovers the other week

)

Dewsbury

Yup correct call, if it had hit him when standing in goal it would have been a try.

Jog on, that can't be right?

What does he teach?

Thats a new one on me

What's the ruling if the ball sinks beneath all that mud?



I'm too young for this to have been the 'norm' in rugby league as I've only been watching since the summer area - certainly great for novelty factor and I bet plenty on here will argue "that's how the game should be played"...

Say what?

Spot on. Someones been reading the rulebook.



The same would apply if the ball is kicked by the attacking team (with territorial advantage) as play has still been irregularly affected.

Thats not right, as mentionned



But if the ball is kicked at the referee its a goal line drop out

anyways thought the ref had a good game tonight given the testing conditions