Gotta be honest here and I'm not saying it for a wind up.

From what I saw of him in the final he looked pretty ordinary


Rusty

What have you done




Its one thing to be a good player over here in SL but there is no hiding place in the NRL for mediocre players. Look at the likes of Thorman, Tansey and Ellis.

I've always had a soft spot for Souths but even though the NRL has to help developing nations by encouraging clubs to sign o/s players I really wish he had gone somewhere else other than the Bunnies


My thoughts are he will struggle in the big time.

Is that when he did Billy Slater like a dog's dinner for his try or were you banging your Barnes' lass when that happened?

Yes. That all you wanted?!

Would that be the Wests player of the year ? And why didnt you mention Morley, was he mediocre ?

Im sure he would'nt be ordinary if Cronulla had signed him

I shall be off to sunny Lonsdale Rd as soon as my jet lag wears off




I've looked at the footage of his try and after recreating it several times using the very latest technology I can confirm that my nan could have scored that one.

What about how he bombed a good chance through being selfish a bit later on?

A pin!

The sharp end!!!!

BM's Knowledge of Rugby League!!!! would probably fit on it and still have 99% of the room available

Wow, Billy Slater must be really crap then.

He makes Dally Messenger look like a serious poster.

We have discussed Ellis many times.

Ill say it again though seeing as you may have missed it.


Certain players need a bit of encouragement in their careers. Tim sheens is no mug. He knows how hard he had to coach Ellis on his arrival....even to do the basics.


Players from developing nations need that little extra at times....its like the dyslexic kid at school who wins an award for spelling.....its sort of an encouragement thing.


And the same applies to Ellis. Sometimes you have to encourage them just that little bit more.

M'lud


I rest my case

Your opinions Barry are the opposite of the likes of Andrew Johns & Peter Sterling, not to mention Big Petero (who Burgess skipped around also for the 1st try)....what do they know eh

He keeps racking the hat tricks up against your lot thought doesnt he

Are you sure you locked the cellar door? Did you soundproof the room? Did you leave her enough food?

Yes, in between getting done like a dog's dinner by the player you think's crap.

Sterlo cracks a fat for anything English....as does AJ

I suspect its the illicit substances in Joeys case that have confused him



You dont have to be any good to skip round poor old Petrol Seventycentsalitre ....

Another Aussie International who you think's crap.

OK, we have:

Billy Slater
Petro Civoniceva

Any other of your "felllow countrymen" you want to slag off?



Anyone would think you weren't Australian

So let me get this straight...

Ellis was named the Wests player of the year for encouragement rather than being their best player.

And your nan could have scored against Billy Slater, so Burgess isn't that impressive.

And everything anyone with credibility in Australia says isn't important.

Yeah, OK. So tell me, who are you again and why should your opinion matter more than facts and credible opinion?

Petero has been a great player in the past but personally I think its about time he came to superleague.

Slater?


Billy Slater is fantastic, my comments were tongue in cheek

Indeed.

On behalf of all members of RLFANS.com I would like to welcome back Barry Mckenzie to these boards. I'm sure you'll all agree, we're the richer for it.

Onya Richie


I'm too jet lagged to disagree with you


Goddamn you Qantas flight 31

The only major airline not to suffer a fatal jet airliner accident. When are you off back home again?

To quote a certain someone....put the mouse down and step away from the keyboard