I know this has probably appeared on here 50 times but what the heck. Which players have lit up superleague better than others in their position, at their peak? here's mine


1 Kris Radlinski
2 Jason Robinson
3 Jamie Lyon
4 Steve Renouf
5 Lesley Vainakolo
6 Henry Paul
7 Robbie Paul
8 David Farleigh
9 Keiron Cunningham
10 Jamie Peacock
11 Adrian Morley
12 Andrew Farrell
13 Paul Sculthorpe

1 Kris Radlinski
2 Jason Robinson
3 Jamie Lyon
4 Steve Renouf
5 Lesley Vainikolo
6 Trent Barrett
7 Andrew Johns
8 Stuart Fielden (Bradford Model)
9 Keiron Cunningham
10 Barrie McDermott
11 Gareth Hock
12 Jamie Peacock
13 Andrew Farrell

I Harris
Robinson
Lyon
Senior
Vianakolo
Paul
Lam/Long
O'Connor
Cunningham
Peacock
Morley
Farrell
Sulthorpe

Lowes
McDermott
Shields
Ali

Swap Long for Robbie Paul and I would agree with that list.

Only the 5 Goons then?

1 - Iestyn Harris
2 - Jason Robinson
3 - Jamie Lyon
4 - Paul Newlove
5 - Lesley Vainakolo
6 - Henry Paul
7 - Sean Long
8 - David Fairleigh
9 - Keiron Cunningham
10 - Jamie Peacock
11 - Andrew Farrell
12 - Ali Lautititi
13 - Paul Sculthorpe

1 Kris Radlinski
2 Scott Donald
3 Jamie Lyon
4 Keith Senior
5 Lesley Vainikolo
6 Iyestin Harris
7 Sean Long
8 Kylie Leuluai
9 Keiron Cunningham
10 Barrie McDermott
11 Adrian Morley
12 Jamie Peacock
13 Paul Sculthorpe

14. Danny McGuire
15. Paul Anderson
16. Iafeta Paleaaesina
17. Kevin Penny

These players have lit up they positions at they [size=200peak[/size. Kevin Penny and Scott Donald have scored some of the best tries in the modern era. Iafeta Paleaaesina is just great to watch and who wouldn’t ant him on your side?

Hmmm I must not be watching the correct league as i could atleast think for penny about 15 better wingers than him atleast, and feka well hes good at impact but 20mins a match could be better. but that is just my opinion

Have we even had 15 super league seasons yet?

Kevin Penny once got in the dream team one year and played very well as I’m sure everyone will agree. But since he has declined on an epic scale. But at his peak he was no doubt up they with the best wingers in super ever IMO.

Feka I’d agree that he doesn’t last long but when he’s on he’s a joy to watch. Its what I like to see on a rugby league pitch.

cheers for a reasoned responce!

Lay off Damo, he's only watched Rugby since 2005.

4 actually

How about when I played rugby when I was younger?

You trying to say there’s rugby league for blind kids now?

5 actually

I wasnt having a go i was just responding to your post.
You dont need 15 seasons to find 15 better wingers than penny. I would say this year we have maybe 3/4 better than him already.

Maybe feka on the bench is a good idea for the peak sl team he can sure demolish most teams as i have seen it first hand

Aww no Wellens?

1 Kris Radlinski
2 Anthony Sullivan
3 Jamie Lyon
4 Paul Newlove
5 Brett Dallas
6 Iestyn Harris
7 Andrew Johns
8 Terry O'Connor
9 Kieron Cunningham
10 Darren Britt (or am I thinking of Fairleigh)
11 Ali Lauititi
12 Andy Farrell
13 Paul Sculthorpe

1. Kris Radlinski
2. Jason Robinson
3. Jamie Lyon
4. Keith Senior
5. Lesley Vainikolo
6. Trent Barrett
7. Andrew Johns
8. Stuart Fielden
9. Keiron Cunningham
10. Barrie McDermott
11. Jamie Peacock
12. Andrew Farrell
13. Paul Sculthorpe

With a bench of:
14. James Roby
15. James Graham
16. Adrian Morley
17. Robbie Paul

I like all the people who haven't listed Andrew Johns at halfback!



I dont think any of these teams would make the NRL finals.

No-one cares.

Of course they would freaky. Most of the players are of unquestionable quality and the positions in which England/GB are dire are supported by Aussie/Kiwi players

Andrew Johns?

he played 3 games

Cunningham over Lowes? I don't think so.