Is it me or is he a waste of money?

He's done nothing this season and is injured most of the time

I think he's on a holiday

It's you.

Carmonts had a better start.

Agreed plus he's on less cash

Put it this way I am more happy with the start George Carmont has made and the wage he is on. Compared to the start Matt King has made and the wage he is on.

I agree, he's still only scored one try that anybody with a bit of pace could have scored and he's not the best defender. For me he comes out the line to fast leaving his wing completely exposed and it doesn't take much to get past a stick in Kevin Penny does it.

I agree. Hes on his jollies.

How much money is he on?



He's missed 2 matches through injury so you're clearly wrong.



I think Wigan are $hite.

Someone is biting at the biscuit of discontent.

But only two points behind Wire. Not a bad effort for "$hite" that.

King Piemon, you are so right as always

I agree. He is rubbish.

Instead of signing King, Monaghan, Hicks & Anderson I am so jealous Wigan signed Coley, Carmont, the Invisible Man & Mathers. Why can't we sign players of that calibre?

But then again, as Maurice said, we're not Wigan are we?

Quote ="griswold"King Piemon, you are so right as always I agree. He is rubbish. Instead of signing King, Monaghan, Hicks & Anderson I am so jealous Wigan signed Coley, Carmont, the Invisible Man & Mathers. Why can't we sign players of that calibre? But then again, as Maurice said, we're not Wigan are we?'" They have been class for you this year not saying they have not but king Carmont is better www.superleague.co.uk/statistics ... eason=2008

Quote ="griswold"King Piemon, you are so right as always I agree. He is rubbish. Instead of signing King, Monaghan, Hicks & Anderson I am so jealous Wigan signed Coley, Carmont, the Invisible Man & Mathers. Why can't we sign players of that calibre? But then again, as Maurice said, we're not Wigan are we?'" They have been class for you this year not saying they have not but king Carmont is better www.superleague.co.uk/statistics ... eason=2008

Quote ="king piemon"They have been class for you this year not saying they have not but king Carmont is better www.superleague.co.uk/statistics ... eason=2008'" exactly, thats why I'm so jealous

Quote ="king piemon"They have been class for you this year not saying they have not but king Carmont is better www.superleague.co.uk/statistics ... eason=2008'" exactly, thats why I'm so jealous

Why, do you think it's possible he's on less than Carmont?

Put it this way, even Mr. Overspend himself, Maurice Lindsay, pulled back from the deal King wanted.

Well at least you admit it

King has had an interupted start to the season so far and has been up and down but he's shown enough glimpses from what i've seen to suggest he'll be as good a buy as what everyone expected him to be. It's said about alot of players but he will improve as the pitches improve especially if that comes on the back of an injury free run in the team.

As for Carmont he's been great for us so far and miles better then what we thought we were getting. I expected another Vaealiki just on far less money when in reality we've got a centre who has abit of everything and works his knackers off for far less money.

Top stuff.

Quote ="king piemon"They have been class for you this year not saying they have not but king Carmont is better www.superleague.co.uk/statistics ... eason=2008'" Some interesting stats there. Who would people say the most on form centre is in super league? Arguably I'd have to say Matt Gidley tell me if you don't agree. Compare the stats: [urlhttp://www.superleague.co.uk/statistics_player.php?hs1=2008&hp1=920&hs2=2008&hp2=2596&stat=tries&season=2008[/url Carmont has better statistics than Matt Gidley and that is a player who has played the exact number of games.

Quote ="king piemon"They have been class for you this year not saying they have not but king Carmont is better www.superleague.co.uk/statistics ... eason=2008'" Some interesting stats there. Who would people say the most on form centre is in super league? Arguably I'd have to say Matt Gidley tell me if you don't agree. Compare the stats: [urlhttp://www.superleague.co.uk/statistics_player.php?hs1=2008&hp1=920&hs2=2008&hp2=2596&stat=tries&season=2008[/url Carmont has better statistics than Matt Gidley and that is a player who has played the exact number of games.

Jake Webster another centre in top form for Hull KR.

Carmont's statistics more than match his as well.

[urlhttp://www.superleague.co.uk/statistics_player.php?hs1=2008&hp1=2357&hs2=2008&hp2=2596&stat=tries&season=2008[/url

Carmont has certainly proved a great buy from the Wigan club.

You beat me to it and his stats against Kings are [url=http://www.superleague.co.uk/statistics_player.php?hs1=2008&hp1=2357&hs2=2008&hp2=2250&stat=tries&season=2008better[/url* although anyone would be stupid to write King off, he's a quality act but been very unlucky with injuries so far. I'm sure once the pitches firm up then we'll see the true Matt King.

*My only concern so far of Jake Webster is his tackling at times but he's certainly made up for it with crucial tries.

He's been very good for you men this year thats why i have just put him in my fantasy team

Jake does seem to lack agility in the tackle at times.

Great try scoring record and very few tries scored down the left hand side but worries me that Darrell Goulding danced around him several times on Monday!

Ryan Atkins stats as a try scoring centre are superb if you look at them. He's made massive yards and got his share of trys.

He'd be in my world cup squad.

As the years roll by plenty of good centres will have Goulding dance round them. A cracking prospect and has held his own in battles with some top draw centres this year.

He has things to work on but the signs are good and need to be from Englans point of view.

Martin Gleeson looks to be finally displaying the form of his Saints days for the wire.

Goulding had a cracking game on monday. Kept an on form Jake Webster quiet.