I see that the Wigan fans are getting a tad defensive when their players abilities are being questioned



Please enlighten me as to which of your Wigan players that have played over in the NRL has earned adulation and respect from the Aussies?

Joe Burgess was a flop at the Roosters and merely a squad filler at Souths who only got a gig cos Maguire was coach there
Sam Tomkins was nothing more than a bang average player in the NRL despite being on mega bucks,He wasn't even in the top bracket of full backs
Mossop was bloody awful over there at Parramatta,before returning to Wigan and being bloody awful there too
Sarginson will be back in SL very shortly and probably at Wigan as he is nowhere near good enough for the NRL

IMO players like Morley,Ellis&Sam Burgess have earned the ultimate respect over there and even Tom Burgess and George Burgess have earned far more respect from the Aussies than the Wigan flops that have come home with their tails between their legs

lmao thats stretching it a bit.....

Well Josh Hodgson seems to be making a good fist of it. Does that mean I have the right to criticise Wigan's NRL duds?

Anyone can criticize anyone. I don't agree with this idea that because your team has had less players go to the NRL you can't comment - however, you have to be able to back up why they were duds, surely?

Why is that stretching it? He's a Wakefield academy product, plus he was far more successful over there than any Wigan players have been in recent years.

Just for balance, despite his own views on how he went, Hardaker was a dud last year. It would be really interesting to see how the 2015 or 2017 version of Hardaker would go in the NRL, but last year he went over after half a season of not bothering for Leeds and was unsurprisingly poor at the Panthers - especially physically.

IMO there are no SL outside backs who are "NRL ready". There are a few who I'm sure could make it if they stuck at it - Burgess is one, Manfredi looks big enough, Ryan Hall (a few years ago), Watkins McGillvray etc. They all need to learn to defend and attacking plays, but the physical side is something that seems to be ignored.

I think forwards generally adapt better, partly because their role is simpler, but also because the best forwards clearly enjoy the tough stuff. Going to a physically harder competition is challenge they relish - unlike most outside backs....