Quote ="Wellsy13"So a completely neutral tone if voice? No facial expressions or gestures? These communicate more than your words ever could.'"
I can't answer that - as I didn't have anyone filming me explaining it at the time, funnily enough
Anyway, I think my mates are intelligent enough to form their own opinions on it without me having to change my tone of voice or make hand gestures...
Quote ="Wellsy13"I wasn't referring to the NFL play offs. That wouldn't be like for like.
Explain to me the structure of the NFL. Go on...'"
You were the one who mentioned the 'Super Bowl' as if it was some ridiculously complex structure that no one understands! If that isn't referring to the NFL play-offs what is?
OK... seeing as you asked.
32 teams, spilt in to two conferences (4 divisions of 4 teams in each conference)
Division winners and the two teams with the next best record in each conference progress to play-offs (12 teams). Top two teams in each conference get a week off, other 8 teams start knock out phases. Straight knock out to the SB.
Quote ="Wellsy13"I can explain the SL play offs in a few words. Top 8 play each other once in round robin, then top four play semis and a final. Complicated? Not at all.'"
You might be be to explain the play-offs in a few words - try the whole system to a non-RL fan and see the reaction you get!
Quote ="Wellsy13"You clearly have an agenda.'"
My 'agenda' is wanting the sport in this country succeed. I just can't see how this new structure will help that. I hope I'm wrong! I really do.
Quote ="Wellsy13"For someone saying there needs to be creativity, you've not thought out of the box there at all.
Here's a thought... sell a season ticket for 14-15 games. If you get a 15th game, bonus! If you don't, better luck next year.'"
If it was that simple, how come clubs haven't been doing that to include play-off games to get better crowds in?
Quote ="Wellsy13"A trophy is a trophy. Is it any more meaningless than the NRC?'"
I'd say yes actually - it probably is. The top four teams are all playing for a trophy when those four, plus two below them, are already promoted.
What I don't really get either... is why they aren't playing a Grand Final in the division below the SL 'Super 8'? Why one and not the other? You could still have 'the million pound game' between 4 and 5, 1 straight to GF, and 2 v 3... That way you'd still have 'Champions' of each division decided by a GF?
As it stands for 2015 (I'm fairly sure this is right, but stand to be corrected):
Super League - Top four play-off, straight knock out, GF
Qualifiers - No play-off or GF to decide Champions, 4 v 5 play-off for promotion
Championship Shield - Same as SL
Championship 1 - 1 v 2 for first promotion spot, then loser joins 3-5 in straight knock out for play-offs for 2nd promotion spot
What a mess.