I would throw Gareth Hock into that as well, the aussies never liked playing against him for GB and i doubt they would now either.

James Roby could play in the NRL for sure imo but a hooker isnt really a proper forward in todays game!!

MoS lost all meaning when Pat Richards won it imo, scoring 15 walk ins and 15 from kicks does not constitute a MoS award even if you are a good kicker.

He could have won back of the year because of that but definitley not MoS imo!!

On that description then I give you Craig Gower..... Smashed all over the park every week and still gets back up and goes back for more !!

Oh yes he doesn't count as us down south know now't about the game do we ???

That's probably the thickest thing I've ever read on RLFANS.

Embarrassing.

Can Tomkins really even be considered for this now? I didn't watch much of Wigan early in the season, but I've watched all of their recent televised games and I'm struggling to think of a game where he's impressed. He was shocking against Saints, just seems his form has disappeared.

Scott Dureau all the way, best player in Super League by a distance.

Tomkins' form has dipped recently, theres no doubt about that. Roby and Westwood may get a look in because of this, but I still think Sam has a good chance.

Tommy Leuluai for me, esp with the way he sat up and smashed his water bottle down in frustration after breaking his leg