Quote ="mystic eddie"Tony Smith took over Wire when they were pretty much rock bottom of the league and going nowhere, thanks to the "efforts" of a guy that plenty on here would bizarrely like to see return to Odsal despite having a less than sparkling effort.'"
You don't actually know when Smith got the job, do you!?
Don't think I recall many people if any wanting Lowes as head coach. As assistant would be a different proposition, maybe.
Quote ="mystic eddie"Smith in mid season had to ship out the odd "troublemaker" in quick time and yet still managed to lead them quickly up the table'"
Look - he led them to a lower league position than McNamara led us. End of. Stop trying to spin the unspinnable.
Quote ="mystic eddie" Fair enough, Wire did not make the 8 but they were well out of the picture anyway when Smith came along. '"
Quote ="mystic eddie"I reckon that a comfortable league improvement and a Cup Win in about five months is a pretty decent return TBF.
After all, if WE had won the cup, you would likely be quickly on here in order to gloat that a CC win is a sign of McNamaras quality. '"
It would be curmudgeonly to belittle their achievement, but if we had drawn York and Featherstone in the first couple of rounds I reckon McNamara might just have plotted a way to defeat them too. Then they scraped past HKR on a golden point, in a match KR blew as you well know.
Quote ="mystic eddie"As for the end of the season? I agree that improvement has been shown but it was all too little too late. '"
Got a degree in stating the bleedin' obvious?
Quote ="mystic eddie"An early cup exit and a failure to reach the play-offs represents a very poor season and I fail to see why anyone could feel any different.'"
Who does?