Read my analysis and you may figure out why



Burgess is a better player

, but for what JD does for our team he would have to go infront of burgess in that posistion. For any other team i wouldnt hesitate in putting burgess infront of JD

Lets face it you havent had a lot to laugh about this season have you so its understandable. I think most of your fans would settle for a win and those what are hard to please at best a thrashing. It is only a game you know

You don't think Andy Lynch would get in your team ahead of Wilkes, Snitch, Bibey, Sculthorpe or Moore?

I'd rather have Wilkes, Moore and Stosic. Snitch plays second row and Sculthorpe does a job from the bench. I like how Bibb is coming along and our forwards are working really well as a unit. I don't imagine with a fully fit side that Bibey would play, but to be fair he has done a job when he's played.

Even with the injuries we've suffered our forwards are still playing superbly and Wilkes in particular with Stosic before his injury we're outstanding. Lynch is a good player but i can't say i'd be bothered if we signed him or not as i'm happy with what we've got.

Over Lynch?
Dear me.

.

Oh and you know that from your limited knowledge of watching both, oh dear another person who only see's the name - now I'm laughing.

So basically you're a one man team. One narrow win and you're bragging already - how sad.

Menzies is a hero of mine and I would have him in my team - TEAM is the word here - is he part of a team?

I suggest that, notwithstanding how absurd or otherwise some of these comparisons might appear to some to be, it might be prudent to keep our powder dry till after the match? I've learnt from long experience that these sort of things have a nasty habit of coming back and biting you.

Like the chant of "easy" did at Cas the other week.

Anyway, player comparisons will always be subjective!

Grow up son, points in the bag suggest your making a bigger fool of yourself than normal.

Well said. Best to crow after the event from experience.

Of course it's subjective, some of the cloth heads on here probably won't of seen half the players they are dismissing play and have absolutely no idea what they are on about.

I'd take any number of Bradford players - what stuns me is that some on here want to laugh at it the other way around. Which is odd when you consider that 3 of your best Jeffries, Tadulala and Solomona came from errr who was it now and a fourth Halley has come back to you from err who was it now twice the palyer he was. Some very stupid people on this forum.

What? This is a player comparison.

Menizes is a better, centre, stand off and any position in the pack and field better than Tony Martin - end of story.

Yes, called Vastman.

Well, whatever. Mind you, he HAS just wound our near-neighbours up with this little gem:


Make of that what you will!

Sorry, but I need to clear up what you're saying here.

Are you meaning by this, that Halley has become twice as good as a result of his 2 month loan at Wakefield?

How the hell is Menzies a better centre you fool. Granted not a better player overall but Martin played and won an NRL Grand Final at centre and playeyed over a 100 times in the NRL in that position which is something Menzies hasn't. Martin is a better centre tha Menzies, even Menzies would admit that - end of story for anybody with a brain.

Fight!!!

Yes he is and yes he is off his rocker.

Must have love, because when he joined us most of you lot were telling us he was cr*p. So are you saying he is still crap - you see the crud posted by the likes of redeverready and others tends to come back and bite the more sober Bulls fans.

You can't win this one - what was said is public record so if he is now a good player as many of you are suggesting I'd say that me saying he is twice the player is a touch modest - it's usually a bit further than that from cr*p to good

FYI: You will not find a single post from me criticising Halley. Feel free to go look, there won't be one.

But thank you for clearing that up for me. I just wanted to make sure my eyes weren't deceiving me with what I was reading.

It appears your reputation on these forums is justified.



P.S. Please don't call me "love". I find one bloke saying that to another, a little off putting.

No I indulge in debate and reasoned argument, you are thick.

This, to you may well appear as being "off ones rocker" when debate for you generally consists of throwing your Special Brew at the telly and shouting abuse at anyone wearing a Rhino shirt who looks old enough, ill enough or small enough for you to feel safe.

Best thread for ages, it shows how far we have fallen when we are even arguing against these set of clowns.

Oh well, hopefully the franchise system will do its job next time round.

Oh ffs, try and read between the lines. I'll explain it to you before you get the reputation for being a dunce.

Of course he isn't twice the player I WAS TAKING THE MICK, though I suspect even someone as clearly over defensive as you would admit his spell at BV has done him no harm.

I was clearly having a dig at those Bulls fans and they know who they are who told us in no uncertain terms that Halley was cr*p, especially at F/B where he was nowhere near as good as the Clown Prince of Fullbacks Mr Pratt sorry Platt.

Now I simply can't believe I'm having to read what you post and explain it to you - your reputation for speed of thought and the ability to spot irony must be truly blinding - luv

And that attitude basically shows why you are now an also ran - pride before a fall.

You need to be superior to have a superiority complex.

Easy Fool, because he simply is, more pace, more skill, better defender you name it Menzies is better except kicking. Menzies has played a shed load of games at centre in the NRL, it wouldn't surprise me if it was rolling upto 100 games in that position. Stop banging on about some average joe like he's a bloomin world beater, he's a bog standard tryer, allways has been and always will be.. Steve Menzies = Better centre than Tony Martin even though he's a second row forward. End of Story.



Really, what reason have you got for thinking Ben Jeffries and David Solomona are our best? Anyone of us will tell you that's not the case.

You spout bovine faeces, little man.