And was apalling. Not sure about Platt. Anyway, h's not eligible to play first team anyway.



Jonathan Thurston has never played a minute of super league, would it be worthwhile throwing him in if we had him? Or Greg Inglis? Or Israel Folau?

If he performs well for the reserves then I'd have no problem playing him. He's a league fan, knows the rules and to top it off he's a professional rugby player. Hardly a big risk is it.

Now you're really clutching at straws. Thurston, Inglis and Folau have all played top grade Rugby League.

Incase you forgot, our new guy hasn't played any level of top grade League, only union and needs a little time to adjust before being thrown in. (even though Wing is pretty much the same, you still need to have a decent knowledge of plays and structure of the game)

Okay. You said SL to begin with not RL. And tbf all he has to do is catch and run, and run the ball in early in the tackle count. It won't really take that much adjusting.

Thankyou.

but you clearly understood what he ment. you're not stupid. you're just arguing for the sake of it. like that monty python arguement sketch. you're just automatically naysaying anything the other person has to say

Maybe.

No he's not...




=white
Sorry though we were doing the MP sketch...?

Heyyy .......

I thought that was another persons job on here.

Sounds a fishy business to me.

How different are the two positions in reality? A union wing and a league wing?
Granted its about learning plays and attacking moves etc (won't take long at the Bulls to be fair will it?

) but the actual role must be pretty similar.

The main difference is that a Union winger doesn't get bombarded by high kicks to the corners like a league winger does.

Also the union winger doesn't take the ball into contact anywhere near as much and I'd also say that they have less to do in contact defence although more in positional defence (if that makes sense.) However, the 2 are certainly more similar now than they used to be and it's probably the easiest position to move codes in.

If we can't play trialists in first team games then we wait to see if he's any good in the reserves then offer him a Rinaldi style contract to test him in the 1st team.

I can't see what we lose by giving the bloke a go.

The most annoying thing about this Rudd story is the Sportinglife RSS.

Anyone who uses it will probably be having the same annoyance I'm having where the Rudd story keep popping up every 10 bloody minutes or so as if it's a new story!

No you didn't

Yes it makes sense, and agree with the general simaralities.
A guy of 6ft and 17 stone could make the transition easier depending on his attitude.
Rudd has long term pedigree, not a has been or never was. Not a wilting violet and been in some top games and had pressure v top opposition.
Current regular player at a RU Premiership Club, and whatever the introverted diehards think, this is a high standard
Dont know what he's like under a high ball but he won't get bounced out of the way.
Big and strong enough to do work in the mid field
Not yet talking him up but hey, his history tells us he might have something to offer better that our current wingers... which in honesty wont take a lot of beating.
Just like him to get the odd pass fron his centres. Lack of which, as expected, might cheese him off.

That's not fair on -the ever hard-working- Tadulala imo.

Yes I agree he always works hard and is honest in his efforts and I really like the guy, he's a gentleman.
But he's neither a winger that has geat pace or guile to beat a defence on his own or altenatively the physical power to bash though them. He's a good finisher when set up. The same lack of attributes make him of limited value when spelling mid field forward runs.

I think his physical power is one of his major attributes, he could teach our props a thing or two as he never takes a backwards step

How did he get on? Anyone see?

He got sin-binned in the first ten minutes. I left at half time, he didn't get another touvh on the ball, buthe was switched Wings so that he could attempt to tackle Pryce who was on fire.

I'm liking the sound of him already.

He's a big unit. Imagine Jon Scales but bigger.