This is who Was best. Are you suggesting that they are past their best?

I could do with one of those too!!

Widening the discussion to all players, not just Bradford ones, who was better:

Andy Farrell or Paul Sculthorpe?

Tough one as both were great players. Farrell probably wasn't as skilful or quick but demanded respect and drove teams forward on his own at times.

Scully had a better all round game for me, probably getting away with it more as he played in one of the best teams for a longer period and wasn't always the "go to" man that Faz invariably was while at Wigan.

I think Scully was the better player, but I'd rather have Faz at his peak and the leadership qualities. Wonder if my decision on Faz is clouded by our lack of a vocal leader in recent years.

Andrew Johns or Darren Lockyer......

Farrell mainly for the reasons above but i just feel Farrell had that extra something special in the bigger games.

You've gone and done it now. Johns Vs Lockyer. For me it is Johns. I was introduced to NRL by watching his Newcastle Knights and the class and skill he possessed as well as unbelievable aura of rugby league royalty was enough for me to support the Knights down under. For me he is the greatest of all time. Lockyer has arguably the same skill set and i can understand why someone would pick him but Johns just had a 'Va Va Voom' in attack and his tackling was top notch too, better than Lockyer's may i add!

Whatever they say, it's going to the Court of Appeal.

playing wise johns had more tricks lockyer was ALOT ALOT ALOT more professional so i would choose lockyer as he was the better bloke and in all honesty there wasn't much difference in skill wise. if johns wasn't as good as he was he would of been kicked out of the Nrl. even though he is a very good match reporter for the nrl.

i dont want to comment on who was better between scully and farrell as i would be very biased and rightly so. but one thing i have to say is i never fully understood why people say farrell wasn't very skillfull and i know you didnt say he wasn't skillfull but i have read it before hes passing was imense and offload and you dont have to even ask about hes kicking skills. I really do think hes last few season at wigan did him a disjustice when people remember him as player as they think more of hes leadership abillties than hes rugby skills.

I too would go for Farrell over Sculthorpe.

As for Johns and Lockyer it's too difficult but as they played different positions it doesn't matter.

Wally Lewis or Darren Lockyer?

Ellery Hanley or Andy Farrell?

Fair old player though Farrell was . . you shurley cannot be serious?

Sculthorpe > Farrell

Farrell was nowhere near the player Sculthorpe was.

Stuart Cummings or Russell Smith ????

Not really no!

Nathan McAvoy 2nd time round or Stuart Reardon 2nd time round.

Still not had an answer on Jamie Peacock or Mike Worrincy from page 2 yet. I know it's a really tough one but someone must have an opinion.

That's a tough one. I'd probably go for McAvoy as at least he could catch.

I too would go for Farrell above Sculthorpe but I don't think there is too much between them

McAvoy Version 2.0 was better than Reardon 2.0. McAvoy was just so slow it was hard to believe but his tackling/passing/catching/being less Sh!t/attacking was just better all round ,2nd time.

McAvoy's hair first time v McAvoy's hair second time.

i can't believe that an ex player can go on to be a referee and show no impartiality in games involving his old side
and no ganson never played for us

You are correct in that. Smithy was far from impartial when he reffed us, in fact he was so determined to show he wasn't favouring us that I don't think we got a single fifty fifty from him in his entire career.

If you want to set up a pressure group to prevent former players having the whistle in games involving their previous club, I'll be the second member.

Phil Ford or Semi Tadulala?

James Lowes or Keith Bridges?

Tame Tupou or . . . . . . . . . . Karl Pryce?

Ford, despite his treachery.

Lowes.

Difficult one to call. I'll say Bridges as I can't remember Lowesy winning too many against the head.....