Marc Herbert is not good enough. Coming back from injury or not, he doesn't have it.

Good for you. Hopefully most fans will give him a fair run to prove himself.

Well if you said it it must be true. Herbert out!

Herbert is not up to it, what about Sykes, Ah Van, Raynor, Kearney, Whitehead, Sibbit, Kopczak who all played pi$$ poor today? Herbert has had 2 games and produced more than Briggs and Sykes (who have been in halves) put together. Herbert was the reason why we didn't lose 50-0.

He'll get a fair run, but at the end of it you will be agreeing.

Hope we get Briggs back soon so weve got somebody out there with some idea.

It was a mix bag from him today, but he did some good stuff and I thought overall was one of the better performers in a pretty poor display.

I dont disagree with you, but he's not good enough none the less. A poor mans Dobson and he's not all that good either.

I think he's shown enough to prove he'll be a solid super league player. Even though i think we need at least one real quality half, neither herbert or briggs will let the bulls down as much as the temp options in the team.

I think we still need to let this team settle. Only 5 games in. I am usually pretty harsh on the team, but even i feel we need to give this side time. It's much more about winning games at home, than expecting a result at the likes of Huddersfield.

Though the defence for Grix's try is as bad as you will ever see.

To use the word defence is an insult.

How the hell can you bring Briggs into this? Briggs was fantastic against Leeds.

He certainley was Paul, we're desperate for him back.

He was fantastic against Leeds but what im saying is Herbert has produced more than both him and Sykes, was more of a pop at Sykes showing how poor he has been. If you get what I mean.

herbert did more than anyone else did today dont understand why people are having a go at him ?
mom for me with lynch pushing him close
did no one see the try he scored ?......matt orford esc. ran along spotted a gap ..kick through and chased up to beat a winger to the ball ...sheer individual brilliance which was needed because no one else was doing anything

Give the lad a chance FFS!

Finally someone agrees with what I'm trying to say.

he was the one player who did something today
when your team arent doing anything someone hasto stand up and do something...may it be you 1,6,7 or 9...nothing was coming from the others so well done marc

He did nothing until the last 10 mins.

Ah, another B4C2010 comment on a player.

And as usual shows a complete lack of knowledge of what makes a good player or the requirements for a position.

Everything good we did today came from Herbert. Given the lack of power from our forwards, it wasn't unexpected that our halves were unable to get any control of the game.

you obviously missed his earlier swipe at O'brien who did nothing wrong for a player on debut IMO.

I really hope we pick up B4C2010 onto our coaching staff. His superior knowledge of player ability and requirements to play in SL could really help Potter out, as he clearly doesn't know what he's doing.



Who did?

IMO we need a Burrow/ Robinson-esque player to play alongside Briggs or Herbert.

Or perhaps we should just see how Briggs and Herbert combine once they get a string of games together? Or even better.. when they're playing behind a pack that is pushing the opposition back and giving them some time and space to play in.

True but I think that type of player world work wonders alongside.

Good god, give the guy a chance he`s only played 2 games, there`s long way to go yet and remember we have a new team, miracles don`t happen over night. I know today`s game was really dismal and as a Bulls fan i was pretty disappointed with that lack of effort from the players today i`m sure potter will bring major changes to the team and start by dropping paul sykes hopefully will be one of them !