And yet there will be some saying what a wonderful season he has had and how we should sign him up again.

Wrong. Clumsy Idiot.

He may get 3 games but it was clumsy and not for me dirty or malicious .. unlike Wilkin's shoulder to Dobsons face

I thought Meli lined Hall up and swung at his head.
Dirty all day long.

I think you need to take a trip to spec savers but hey ho.

Im there now.
In the queue behind Silverwood.

What will happen with the two players on report?

Give me a sec while I check my crystal ball....

Meli will be out for longer with injury than he will for the ban. Shocking! It was worse than Mathers on King.

After watching it back on Sky Plus, I reckon that's the worst contact with the head I have seen in 30 years. Meli is seriously lucky he didn't kill Hall there, the way his head flopped about knocked me sick.

I would expect the most severe punishment possible from the RFL and I would be disappointed personally if he doesn't apologise and if the club don't condemn him for it and discipline him internally before the disciplinary meets.

It was a stupid and desparate challenge, but he is still worth keeping for one more season, alongside your big mate wello.

I think he could be looking at 8 matches ban.

It was about as bad a challenge as you're likely to see. His only defence is that he wasn't actually trying to kill Hall, and it was gross negligence rather than intent. He might get away with that defence because (a) it was high speed, rather than a head-on-line-'em-up hit; and (b) his previous record is pretty good.

However, it was bad. He'll not be playing for a long time, whether he's dislocated his elbow or not.

God no. Wello is done and Meli proved yet again that he is king brainfart

Saints need to move on and rebuild the team.

Meli has been a good servant to the club, however we need a fresh start from someone else.

Hopefully someone from within but if not sign a young winger from elsewhere is SL.

Very bad challenge. Thought it was stupid and clumsy but don't think he set off to hit hall. As others have said it was a shocking challenge and halls head movement was sickening. Lucky enough he was fine, could have been very bad

This .

It was a bad challenge, but that hardly makes his previous efforts this season worthless.

Will and should get the book thrown at him, but lets not use this as an excuse to ignore his good rugby up until this match.

No previous that he has been caught for. Wasn't it Meli that did for Holdsworth earlier this season and Holdsworth is still feeling the effects.

In a completely legal and legitimate challenge - yes.

Change legal and legitimate to late and you are correct.

You mean like the forward pass he threw earlier in the half just when we'd battled out from our own line? Oh yes. Those wonderful Meli moments that never fail to arise, always, always in knock out games when we most need him to be reliable.

He's a liability and needs to go.

Instead of a grand final, it's a full cup run this time ! Meli is a Wigan spy!

Shocking. Melissa knew what he was doing and got what he deserved. No requirement for the trophy cleaner again at Saibts. It's always your year...

Show us your superleague winners rings ... oh thats right you dont have any do you and your team of geriatrics isnt likely to win one either

.. oh while your at it when were you last champions? It's never your year ....

There wasn't any clumsy in that attack.

It was clearly clumsy