You also said a fullback that makes 9

Thats talking as it stands today 07/08/2011 which is why i also said after in brackets "(need to see how Hohaia goes) which means see how well he does first before saying you need a fullback".

Ahh I get you!

I'm not to sure what we need. I want to know what Royce is going to next season and whether we are going to sign anyone else.

At the moment I'd say we need to replace Wellens, but that may be with Hohaia next season, despite Royce saying he'll be 7. I can't see it happening though. We need a centre better than Meli, but who could we actually sign at the moment? The only thing we could do is wish for Wheeler to come back and work wonders for us, but when is he actually back? I think our wingers are fine and just need time to play and fill out more. We won't know if we need another prop until we play without Graham. We have Laffranchi coming in but next season we should see Carl Forster and maybe Jordan Hand. In regards to needing another 2nd rower like Gilmour, I feel we have enough second rowers, why sign another. It just adds up on the cap for more players that will get less time. The loose forward is fine I feel. Royce has played with Puletua and Wilkin at loose this year. We don't know if he will go for a ball handling loose or a prop type loose.

Fair point but JD could play anywhere from 1-7 he was that good. He played in a widnes backline with players who had the x factor too unlike our back line. Let compare ours to the one in which Davies played in.

1- A Tait v P Wellens
2- A Currier v T Makinson
3- J Davies v M Shenton
4- D Wright v F Meli
5- M Offiah v J Foster
6- T Myler v L Pryce
7- D Hulme v J Lomax

I'm not saying that our backs are rubbish but we do lack that little bit of class which could be rectified as follows IMHO

1- Lomax
2- broughton ( or another winger who can beat a man on the ouside)
3- shenton ( having a new winger might see more ball to show class)
4- meli
5- foster (proven combo with meli now 2 flanks that offer a threat)
6- pryce
7- hohoia

Back now have pace strength and skill with pryce as conductor. Teams would be far more worried by that backline. Also have makinson wheeler and Gaskell fighting for a space on bench as wello would be my bench back to start with for his experience / defense in tight games.


3-

Gary wheeler is back in full training and is available for selection this week.

i went watching the 20s yesterday before the wigan game and wheeler look a couple of weeks off the first team looked very slow playing in the centres the in the halfs second half

Like I said, he's back in full training and available for selection. It's up to Royce if he thinks wheeler is fit enough or not.

i cant see wheeler being in the 19 man squad when it comes out on wednesday we are already playing with too many half fit players who need a op come the end of the season

Lomax isn't a full back, plain and simple. What is the point of wasting his step by shoving him to the back of the field and bringing him in on the 3rd tackle to get mullered by O'Loughlin etc after he has made 10m. He isn't a Tomkins type of player, he is most dangerous with ball in hand attacking players at the line.

We can't make a Sam Tomkins player, the way we play doesnt have that element to it. The three quarters we have now are fine, Meli has been in great form (for him) Makinson is giving 110% every week for a 19/20/21 year old lad playing aginst guys often a lot more developed than him, Shents is getting there but i feel an injury he had at cas might still be with him and why are people getting on Foster's back? He is another Ade but with a phenomenal goal kicking game and probably a little more pace. People on here would still complain about the lack of pace if we had Usain Bolt on the wing.

I agree we are without a game changer but again you dont build Sculthorpe's/Long's etc you have to be patient and see what comes of it. Leon was clearly unfit yesterday, he had a great first half but you can understand why Royce left him on, in 1 second Leon can change a game but unfortunately he didnt. With Leon's (IMO) impending departure Hohaia will play at 6, without doubt. Lomax will carry on at 7 and Makinson should go to full back when Ade comes back fit and ready.

I love you Wello so think about your place at Saints and what you can bring to the team. I agree that we were flat yesterday i think at one point Lomax passed the ball to a standing still James Graham so its not all clicking yet but play Leon against Hudds then dont even take him to Hull the week after and dot he same with Eastmond and Wellens

We used the same move to score both tries and like many have said Shents should have been given the ball more but we were beaten by the better team on defence and they were much much more clinical. I don't think we are too far away but i wouldn't fancy us to beat Warrington or Wigan. They will be at the Grand Final for sure IMO.

Still i was very proud of the lads yesterday, 100% effort on the field and the terraces.

IMO the backs ain't fine, they ain't good enough and we wont win anything with these current backs.

I'm not saying they are rubbish but for us to stay a top 3 side in the next few years and have a chance of winning something we need a centre and a halfback and most prob a prop.

I think the difference on Saturday was, they only needed few chances and they took them, we was camped out on wigans line for 30 mins in the first half and didn't look like scoring.

Meli is doing ok but he's not a centre and is just relying on his strength, the is nothing skillfull about him and he's no chance of creating anything unless he's in their 20 meter. He lacks pace and can be a liability in defense.

Matty Blythe? John Clarke?










Pot Kettle Black.

Don't worry !! Leon Pryce will look world class on Friday night when we (Hudds defence) stand and admire him running through a huge gap to score, i have lost track the number of times in recent years I have seen him score off the same play at knowsley road...... huddersfield have a 'thing' about playing saints away and despite our home win I will be surprised if it doesn't continue Friday but I live in hope... i watched all 38 years of leeds games until this season and was at Knowsley road when we last won..... I live in hope.... just don't bring Kieron Cunningham out of retirement for Friday or I may stay at home.....

I was in the east stand just yards from where we scored our tries and if you don't think he was skillful in his part in them there is no hope to change your opinion on him.

He can be extremely good at drawing in defenders and releasing the ball with just enough space and just the right timing to release Jamie the sparrow down the left hand side. When those two click near the line they are terrific. It's just such a pity it took until the last 15 minutes for them to click. We could have run riot down that edge with more composure.

Yes and I've seen his awful throw it anywhere passes which are totally embarrassing.

Unless we get in there 20 meter, Meli is not useful at all. He will never be a player to score long range try. He's a good finisher and has done ok but he's never a real centre.

On my goodness.

So Shenton is not good enough, basically translates to there is no England centre good enough for Saints.
Meli is not good enough basically translates to there is not a SL centre outside of Carmont from Wigan good enough for Saints.
Foster has no pace, and can't beat a man, yet when he got his hatrick against Catalan's he seamed to beat a few of them for pace.

Makinson well the jury is out, but it is his first year.
Wellens, well there is much agreement on that.

So what is being said is that our 4 players on the wing and centre, must be brought in from NRL, with the exception of Carmont.

Are we living in cloud cookoo land. You can only have 5 overseas under normal rules anymore.

It's just not going to happen, the days of busting the salary cap and packing your squad with kolpak NRL players are gone. If you want to replace any of the above 4 it needs to be done within Saints or other SL clubs.

So unless we are suggesting that the Saints board can buy the wigan backs, this is all completely pointless. Meli has one more year at that point depending on whether some others like Soliola stays we may get a chance to get an NRL centre, but it will not be a top player, it will be someone on a pension or someone struggling to get in. The NRL already beats us hands down money wise and this gap will only increase. We have to make our own or buy from other clubs.

Anyone got any credible suggestions better than what we already have???

So rubbish he's scored three tries less than the top try scorer this year. That's playing outside a player who is apparently never a centre this year.

Yes, he's incredibly rubbish.

Tries.

Whats Matty Blythe or Jon Clarke got to do with anything ?

Lets make a comparison.

1. Michael Shenton a big signing from Cas who who will be on a very good contract and will be one of your top earners, Matty Blythe is basically a kid thats just starting out his career at this level and won't be on much money at all, he's not even a first choice player for us, a squad player thats been on dual reg at Leigh. Hmmmmmm

2. Jon Clarke, a player thats now in the last stages of his career compared to Scott Moore whose only 23. Clarke again is just a squad player so i'm not sure what your point us with any of the above 2.

We had to play Matty Blythe against Wigan because of the injuries to Harrison and Briers, Bridge went to 6 which means Blythe had to come in at right centre to cover for Bridge. He was obviously out of his depth at that level in a game of such importance, what was Shenton's excuse given that he was touted as being one of the best english centres in recent times who has also played for England ? Shenton looked out of his depth against Wigan which would be a worry given he is supposed to be one of (if not) the best english centres in the game. I'd take Chris Bridge all day long ahead of Shenton at right centre, just a pitty we couldn't play him at right centre against Wigan due to injuries.

Wingers' try records are deceptive.

Put bluntly, me and you could have scored both of Foster's tries on Saturday. He had a total of about 4 yards to run.

We'd have been useless at just about everything else mind...

Darrell Goulding was the 2nd highest try scorer last year - he's not even close to being the 2nd best winger.

I think it would be stupid not to play Lance at FB next year...lets be honest when you play in a position for so long like he has, you would be stupid to move him to HB unless it was a one off injury crisis...but they never happen at saints

I'd have Pryce there if recent news is true. He would work very well as a 3rd pivot I feel and isn't a stranger to Full Back. For me Lomax has to stay in the halves, he's the future of this club and that is his native position. As for Lance he has one major flaw, he can't catch a bomb. If you think Meli is bad for it wait until you see Hohaia. This problem is negated if he plays in the halves and so I feel it would best suit the team if he took 6/7. He also has a better kicking game than both Pryce and Lomax, especially short.

We've seen that the lad can finish though, not all those tries have been falling over the line. It was asked what he brought to the team bar goal kicking, given the tribulations we've had as a team this year, he's done well to score an amount of tries comparable to the wingers at Wigan and Warrington, teams that have been far more fluent in attack with more settled teams than us this year.

I don't think Foster is the finished article, nor that he's in the top 2 wingers in the league. But he's shown that he has good hands, knows where the try line is, has a decent turn of pace, is safe under the high ball and isn't error prone.

I just find it a touch ridiculous to write him off as being not good enough now at 21 in his second season because he isn't ripping teams apart playing in a team with a winger as his centre, a full back that's as slow as a tug chiming into the line and has had two rookie half backs for most of the year.

Some players have obvious deficiencies that they never seem to get rid of, Goulding is a good example of that, Foster is not one of those players though.