The same player who was a reliably plodder his whole career in the NRL goes past Michael Shenton and is therefore class, and world class before he did that. Logic bypass.

The logic bypass is that the comparison is with Newlove, who just wasn't special. I know you paid a lot of money (and shipped out players) to sign him, but he was a long way from being a world beater. Carmont has been one of our best overseas signings for many years and was sensational last season. Just watch him in the Exiles game or the WCC. Newlove backed out of playing at international level. I wonder why?

Sorry he went past Newlove did he?

WTF has the try tonight got to do with Newlove?

Are you on drugs again?

The try tonight shows that George is still a class player, though I tend to agree that embarrassing Shenton and Wellens isn't that great an achievement... mind you, that's not Carmont's fault, all he can do is beat what's in front of him....

As for the references to Newlove, please see earlier in the thread!

You mean one post earlier:
"The logic bypass is that the comparison is with Newlove, who just wasn't special".

Had you forgot that with your goldfish like logic?

You're demonstrably a clueless idiot who knows **** all about RL. Or mad. Or a Wigan fan. Or a combination of all 3. Troll off back to your own board and back to rolling in filth with your other inbred brethren before you lose what little comedy value your lunatic half-baked opinions still possess.

33 tries in 83 starts in the NRL. Not bad plodding.

You know what - I'm going to go onto the pie board and start a thread about how Hanley was a decent player, but that he never quite reached the heights that Wilkin has. Let's see how they like being exposed to a little bit of this preposterous and laughable lunacy that some of their more deluded and clueless spawn seem so keen to peddle on us....

remember peter shilton goal keeper for england his nick name was ty ey shilton...exclude shilton cos that what he is....ryan atkins 20000000000000000 million times far better...but then again he plays for saints

What in the love of god are you talking about?

Ok this has been derailed enough, nothing to do with Shenton. It's getting shut down. One off comments fine, but you have harped on long enough.