Willis.


Wooooooooosh!!

Sophie = Saint_Jen.

Really not.

Jamie Lyon was in the top 3 players in the world in his 1st season at saints. Be was pure world class.

IMO tho overall gidley has been just as good if not better. Lyon wasn't as good in his 2nd year but gidley has kept up to the high standard his started at.

If Gidley had followed Gleeson in the #3 shirt as opposed to following Lyon, then he'd probably be regarded as one of the greatest players to have ever played for the club.

His first season was hit and miss, but last year and this year, he has proven that he is lightyears ahead of any other centre playing in this country.

Adie must be constantly jizzing in his pants.

Worst game Gidley ever had for us was the WCC game against the Bronco's, he mus thave given 5 penalties away on his own, he looked otu of sorts and hadnt a clue how we played etc etc... other than that one game he has been rather good and showed he can play on for longer than Darren Smith .

how can he be when Lyon had more aspects to his game. There is no matter of opinion here, that is factually incorrect.

Gidders is way better in defence than lyon was.

No way! Gidley is a good defender but Lyon is as good in defence as any centre in world rugby.

Gidley is a better defender than Lyon.

based on?

Lyon was a good tackler but used to come out of the line unnecessarily on occasion. Gidley is the more positionally savvy defender of the two.

perhaps.

However Lyon completed a greater percentage of his attempted tackles, was pretty good at fielding kicks (high, low or behind him). Id say he's at least as good as Gidley defensively even if Gidley had the upper hand in positioning.