Who?

Debate it all you want, but Manu > Flannery.

Quite... I've heard that Shenton bloke at Cas is quite good?

Happy as Larry.
His performance at the Ethiad the other week Is something weve not had at Saints for a while now.

Perry
Roby
Laffranchi
Sia
Manu
Wilkin

TP
Clough
LMS
Flanaghan

Not bad pack, just wish we could replace perry with a quality prop.

The only games Perry's struggled in of late is the Wigan games. others he's bee impressive.
Given he has the speed of a glacier, I wonder if he struggles with the all round pace that Wigan play with.

I'm starting to become more and more excited about next season; especially with that pack as long as Brown can get the best out of them!

I've been big fan of josh perry for many years and was over the moon when we signed him but it's just not worked out which is a shame because we've not seen Anything like the real josh perry.

We need a more mobile powerhouse style prop that will put himself about and last longer than perry does.

That James graham in the NRL will do.

Gutted to be losing him, I can only hope we have seen the best of him but I doubt very much we have, imo he has a good 3 yrs in him if not more, probably Menzies 2!! who will still be troubling teams in 4 yrs time.

Very pleased with the signing and the length of the contract is spot on for a change.

I see very little risk in Manu playing till he is 34. If he is still firing in his last year, I could see another offer after that, if he wanted it. A real steal from Hull FC.

good to see saints developing their youngsters ,not playing them and signing journeymen.reminds me of a club i support who did the same to their youngsters a few years ago.

Shame about the scrum halves being produced over there

it,s an ordinary signing ,pretty much like luaki coming to wigan. i can,t believe this signing gets saints fans excited.

lol! Yeah really? Manu would walk into Wigan's team, we were well rid of Luaki and couldn't believe Wigan took him. We will be gutted to lose Manu but we need a fresh outlook at Hull so good luck to him.

Oh dear



Someone who uses commas for apostrophes should not be listened to really...

I'd ignored him it looked too obvious for me.

I couldn't resist, unfortunately

We really need a smiley that says warning fisherman at work.



It would go on most of my posts on other boards

hey hey hey, you've made my week forget Manu this is the best signing on this board this week.

Can we get the clown one I've been asking for as well.

what a pathetic post, mnu is arguably the best second rower in the league, weras luaki is a complete baffoon, with a stinking "why me" attitude... best thing fc did was to get rid of that lazy penalty machine, manu on the other hand is a top player end of, and would walk into ANY superleague team if not nrl

Big Willie Video www.superleague.co.uk/article/25 ... on-being-a

Big Willie Video www.superleague.co.uk/article/25 ... on-being-a