From the angle available gotta say nothing in it.

its the best angle you could possibly get, badly timed tackle thats all

I'm getting worried.

Shrek is out for 3 weeks after that hit he took from( think it was either Brian or Cloughie ? ) news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/rugby_l ... 731059.stm

Shrek is out for 3 weeks after that hit he took from( think it was either Brian or Cloughie ? ) news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/rugby_l ... 731059.stm

You know what they say - in the kingdom of the blind......

Quote ="Supreme Sydney2002"Shrek is out for 3 weeks after that hit he took from( think it was either Brian or Cloughie ? ) news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/rugby_l ... 731059.stm'" Tbh, as much as you want /some/ bragging rights, I doubt that a 'hit' would cause that calf tear.

Quote ="Supreme Sydney2002"Shrek is out for 3 weeks after that hit he took from( think it was either Brian or Cloughie ? ) news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/rugby_l ... 731059.stm'" Tbh, as much as you want /some/ bragging rights, I doubt that a 'hit' would cause that calf tear.

I just have seen the hit on Robes on Boots and All and there was nowt wrong with it.

From an outsiders opinion, it looks to me as if O'Meley did lead with the forearm/elbow.

Get your eyes tested, every person except you who have seen the incident, including ever Saints fan has said there was nothing in it.

Nah. It was the angle Robes was running on which gave that impression at first. It is so rare to see Roby make a mistake in the tackle, but he surely did this time.

I just hope he is ok because I really think it's poor to ask him to play this Saturday after receiving such a hammering on Friday.

Outside what, the real world?

What's the point in having at go at me because my opinion doesn't match yours?

Pause it at the exact point of impact and in my opinion the elbow region makes contact with the head and the forearm has been raised.

Hull fans are bound to have a go! They were having a go at Saints fans about this long before the RFL even thought about it.

I wasn't having a go, though. I just don't think there was really a case for it. Very unusually, I think Robes got his angle wrong when tackling and came off the worse for it.

Oh no I know you weren't having a go, it was those two Hull morons who were trying to be comedians.

Bit too quick to say never!!!

Because you are quite clearly wrong.

Everyone can see it even biased Saints fan admits there was nothing wrong with it.

Thats because it was Saints fans like you, who hadn't seen the incident, going on about it, you should have waited until you had seen the incident.

All the Hull fans where correct weren't there, so there posts are jusified?

Except Saints fans like me weren't stating categorically that it was illegal play, just stating that a report had been made (in my case on the Sky red button show) that it [imight[/i have been illegal play.


As it turned out, Hull fans were correct, yes. However, they were denying everything from the outset, so no, the early posts weren't justified.

OK Dave don't beef about it

Interesting avatar you have there

Shoulder and you know it!

Thats only because it is attached to the elbow by the arm.

Yup, both are classic cases of [ileading with the face[/i.

Should be banned.