True. And the combined impact of the 'great' Danny Buderas and Eastwood to date, is what precisely?

Swap you Mills and Wheeldon for them two

No deal noel!

Another red vee man of stellios award goes to Tony P. With Frank P getting next years

He's solomona like in his offloads, just 3 times the size

If you check the Superleague stats he tops in every category for a forward. Metres gained, tackles, offloads, tries, tackle busts the lot.
Best forward since Fairleigh in my opinion.

For Saints you mean?
Not overall?

Sorry not top
Still happy he is in the Red [size=150=redV[/size
TP
Position 12
Shirt number 16
Appearances 3
Tries 2
Try assists 0
Goals 0
Drop Goals 0
Meters 416
Carries 51
Tackles 74
Offloads 10
Attacking Kicks 0
Runs from dummy half 2
Tackle Busts 10
Marker tackles 4
Clean Breaks 2
Forty twenty 0
Kicks in general play 0
Missed goals 0
Missed tackles 3
Errors 0
Penalties 2
Red cards 0
Yellow cards 0

Jamie Peacock
12 Position
10 Shirt number
3 Appearances
0 Tries
0 Try assists
0 Goals
0 Drop Goals
421 Meters
64 Carries
91 Tackles
3 Offloads
0 Attacking Kicks
1 Runs from dummy half
5 Tackle Busts
13 Marker tackles
0 Clean Breaks
0 Forty twenty
0 Kicks in general play
0 Missed goals
3 Missed tackles
2 Errors
3 Penalties
0 Red cards
1 Yellow card

Peacock plays as prop though, Tony is a second rower.

Did I say anything about them two??? NO! I was just saying it's a little early in the season to be saying players will be MOS and how they are the greatest signing!

20 minutes off the bench and a rejected visa for speeding.

Is it?

Oh right. Better lock this then and severely fine anyone involved in the thread.

How do you rate Menzies performances in comparison?

I think there profits are well down this financial year.

I've not seen much of him, but just looking at the superleague stats says he has not been in the same league(yet) 160 mtrs vs 416, 0 tries vs 2, 5 tackles bust vs 10, 6 errors vs 0, 0 clean breaks vs 2. Stats are never the full story but these pretty convincing

BOTH fowards, he said of any forward

Think Tony is almost equal on metres and tackles, the significant difference is Tony has done a lot more offloads, less errors, less mis tackles and less penalties than Peacock.

Danny Tickle has some impressive stats and seems to be the form forward at the moment.

I reckon it will be Tony the top forward by the time Easter comes around and will be on the M.O.S radar.

Fair enough. But they are a diiferent style of player.

We'll how Menzies compares on Saturday, he'll play for the Bulls against Wigan on TV.

I dont see how playing against the ferocious might of wigans forwards is fair test of Menzies ability

Hold on, you stated Puletua was the best import. How can you say that without seeing the others?

because i can use the stats to back up my argument?! Whats your point?

You're using half the facts

i happen to think that tony has been better in superleague so far, only 3 matches in, if Menzies turns out to be better i'd happily agree but how is he better currently?

Tony P doesn't spend as much time in the bin as Jamie P