I honestly thought he was the worst player on the pitch against Barrow. He took the wrong option nearly every time he had the ball, and threw some stupid passes. I'm really starting to think he's not good enough.

Wello
lomax
gidley
wheeler
meli
pryce
roby
jammer
KC
tonyp
clough
dixon
flannery

moore
foz
ashurst
bryn

I know what your saying, he throws silly balls and gives pens away but it's hard to judge until KC retires and moore gets his chance proper.

Soom weeks i think this lads the perfect replacement for kc then the next i think he ain't good enough. He still only young lad, we will find out next year just what moore is made of.

3

He was poor,but he needs an extended run at hooker before we can judge him IMO.
He's no scrum half anymore that's for sure.

re scott moore
last year he was great at huddersfield,earning an international cap.i think the trouble this year is that he is constantly playing in different positions.as st pete says,once kc retires and moore is given a more permanent position,we will only then find out if he is good enough.

Just said more or less same thing, we won't know if moore is good enough until he takes over from kc next year.

I hope he does and he's got all the tools to do it.

www.redvee.net/viewpage.php?page_id=2 1. wellens 2. lomax 3. gidley 4. wheeler 5. meli 6. pryce 7. roby 8. graham 9. cunningham 10. puletua 11. ashurst 12. clough 13. flannary 14. moore 15. emmitt 16. hargreaves 17. dixon

www.redvee.net/viewpage.php?page_id=2 1. wellens 2. lomax 3. gidley 4. wheeler 5. meli 6. pryce 7. roby 8. graham 9. cunningham 10. puletua 11. ashurst 12. clough 13. flannary 14. moore 15. emmitt 16. hargreaves 17. dixon

Wello
lomax
gidley
wheeler
meli
pryce
Gaskell
jammer
KC
Bryn
clough
dixon
flannery

Roby
foz
ashurst
Puletua

Id like to see what Gaskell can do,he has a kicking and we'll need it on that big pitch of Hulls.

the problem is with scott moore is his handling, get him working on that and he will be a fine player

No chance Gaskell will start at 7.

3?

I'd agree with yourself and St.Pete that it's difficult to judge due to him being moved around alot, but based on what hes done so far this season, i don't think he's good enough. He's done some good things, but i think the bad outweigh the good. As you rightly say, he's been moved around a lot and this is bound to effect him, hopefully he proves me wrong when he is given the chance of proving his worth in the hooking role. He was very poor at scrum half though.

I think he has but I think his confidence Is taking a knock playing here there and everywhere.

Probably,but that's what Id like to see.

He's living in kc and robys shadow at the moment as he's third choice hooker, he prob feels a little put out but i think he will step up next year.

Hull will look something like:

1. Tansey
2. Whiting
3. Turner
4. Yeaman
5. Briscoe
6. Washbrook
7. Long
8. O'Meley
9. Berrigan
10. Radford
11. Manu
12. Tickle
13. Fitzgibbon

14. Moa
15. Lauaki
16. Dowes
17. Houghton

Horne could be fit aswell but I think he will miss out.

Take Briscoe out that back line and it's far worse than Saints

Should be a breeze for you guys then

Not with your forward pack it wont. Hull will be rightly massive favourites but i always have faith in our lads and we've done it hard all season. Aslong as Graham plays, anything is possible.

Very true about Graham...the guy is awesome

I disagree, Saints probaly have the edge but Tansey has caused problems for every team we have played, Whiting lacks pace but is very reliable, Turner is quick and strong and has the potential to make a very good centre and Yeaman is in the best form since 2006.

I wouldnt mind Yeaman in the redvee tbh

Your definitely one for grand statements... we have a "far worse" back line but are "massive" favourites?



Anyway, fingers crossed this is lining up to be a good game.

Hull are strengthened after a few weeks of been unlucky in the injury department, and we all know that Saints are more than capable of producing fantastic rugby.

Should be a good crowd as well.

Think Yeaman would do well with Saints fast play, although you might as well tell your wingers to stay at home.

am most certain this was said prior to our game at the start of the season!

One of the most over-rated backs around IMO. A poor man's Talau.