If you look on the Warrington board I also suggested Neil Fox as he is the highest points scorer in a Challenge Cup final.

But I still think Shaun Edwards Wembley record eclipses all other candidates. Isn't this an open forum?

There's been nothing open about your contributions on this thread though

.

Good job at reeling in that last one, though.

So somebody perhaps perceiving it as celebrating the career of one individual over the sport is enough for you to suggest pulling the plug on what could be a great piece of sporting art? I cannot see why somebody thinking differently to what the art actually is is a risk. What's the worst that can happen? That fool goes home with the wrong of image of RL in their head? Big deal. Come on! We're Saints fans and we're RL fans. We know that RL has always been about taking risks so just do it. Choose life!

If it's anyone other than Hanley in going to knock the thing down when saints play there next august bank holiday.

I think you must have missed my previous post [url=http://viewtopic.php?p=16531958#p16531958here[/url because I've put to bed the question of Edwards in it.

Vote Offiah/Fox.

Not to you it isn't. It's closed to all Wigan fans but most of all those who call themselves Rogues Gallery.

Shaun Edwards is a Union man. He doesn't represent League. I don't care whether he wears cherry and white undies and kisses the Wigan crest every night, he no more represents Rugby League than does Prince Charles.

And if it's not in this pose:



I'm knocking the bugger down!

I'm quoting wikipedia here so apologies for any incorrect facts but...

"For his work as a manager and as a radio commentator resulted in the Lance Todd Trophy being named after him."

Exibit A) M'lud...

I'm connected. I won't allow it.

Vote Offiah/Fox!

and



Vote Bailey and Offiah

Sorry to have to educate you again



I said Neil Fox, the all time Rugby League points scorer.

Pay attention.

Of course he represents Rugby League. He is the most decorated player in RUGBY LEAGUE. and has appeared and won more at Wembley (where the statue is to be erected) than ANY other RL player. His present position is irrelevant.

Have you ever heard him denounce Rugby League or dismiss his roots?

If the RFL (and Eric Hughes) hadn't been so bloody stupid Edwards would still have been a part of RL today. There was a very interesting piece on Shaun in Fridays Evening Post, it may be available on line. I suggest you read it, but somehow doubt you will.

I don't care. He is automatically linked with RU regardless of his 'roots'. It would be daft to have a statue of someone better known in RU than RL when we are supposed to be representing RL.

But he's not better known in Rugby Union, he's far better known as a Rugby League player and for his records in OUR game.

You're doing the Saints thing and disregarding Rugby League history.

Why any Saints supporter would want one of the biggest twunts to grace the planet[Martin Offiah to be immortalised forever to represent our game and to feed his already humongous ego i don't know?

Quote ="Rogues Gallery" If the RFL (and Eric Hughes) hadn't been so bloody stupid Edwards would still have been a part of RL today. There was a very interesting piece on Shaun in Fridays Evening Post, it may be available on line. I suggest you read it, but somehow doubt you will.'" Or read here findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_q ... n14506027/ He left because he wanted to be near his family in London and he wasn't allowed to day off a week by the Evil Eric Hughes. He is in union because he got a good job offer, gets paid well and can still be near his son so please stop blaming everybody Rogues. Who know if he would have made a great Rugby league coach , for all we know he could have been another Fat Gary Schofield. great full time professional team (with some truly great players) + massive transfer fee's + gargantuan wage bill + part time opposition = large medal collection for lucky Mr Edwards.

Quote ="Rogues Gallery" If the RFL (and Eric Hughes) hadn't been so bloody stupid Edwards would still have been a part of RL today. There was a very interesting piece on Shaun in Fridays Evening Post, it may be available on line. I suggest you read it, but somehow doubt you will.'" Or read here findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_q ... n14506027/ He left because he wanted to be near his family in London and he wasn't allowed to day off a week by the Evil Eric Hughes. He is in union because he got a good job offer, gets paid well and can still be near his son so please stop blaming everybody Rogues. Who know if he would have made a great Rugby league coach , for all we know he could have been another Fat Gary Schofield. great full time professional team (with some truly great players) + massive transfer fee's + gargantuan wage bill + part time opposition = large medal collection for lucky Mr Edwards.

Me either. If Offiah was even half as good as he thought he was he would have made the truely greats like Billy Boston and Vol look like Danny Arnold.. worlds biggest ego

And your doing the Wigan thing by attempting to convince people that Rugby League in this country in the late 80's and early 90's was anything but a one sided farce.

Quote ="No1 Saint"Or read here findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_q ... n14506027/ He left because he wanted to be near his family in London and he wasn't allowed to day off a week by the Evil Eric Hughes. He is in union because he got a good job offer, gets paid well and can still be near his son so please stop blaming everybody Rogues. Who know if he would have made a great Rugby league coach , for all we know he could have been another Fat Gary Schofield. great full time professional team (with some truly great players) + massive transfer fee's + gargantuan wage bill + part time opposition = large medal collection for lucky Mr Edwards.'" That article just proves my point about Edwards and Wembley, thank you 43 games unbeaten, youngest EVER Wembley captain. Most decorated RL player EVER. He must be so lucky, it's a wonder he ever kept his place at Wigan with all those massive transfer fees that were available to replace him I wonder what his lottery numbers are? Again thank you for proving a point. There's nothing like a bitter/jealous Saints fan. I love it.

Quote ="No1 Saint"Or read here findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_q ... n14506027/ He left because he wanted to be near his family in London and he wasn't allowed to day off a week by the Evil Eric Hughes. He is in union because he got a good job offer, gets paid well and can still be near his son so please stop blaming everybody Rogues. Who know if he would have made a great Rugby league coach , for all we know he could have been another Fat Gary Schofield. great full time professional team (with some truly great players) + massive transfer fee's + gargantuan wage bill + part time opposition = large medal collection for lucky Mr Edwards.'" That article just proves my point about Edwards and Wembley, thank you 43 games unbeaten, youngest EVER Wembley captain. Most decorated RL player EVER. He must be so lucky, it's a wonder he ever kept his place at Wigan with all those massive transfer fees that were available to replace him I wonder what his lottery numbers are? Again thank you for proving a point. There's nothing like a bitter/jealous Saints fan. I love it.

How many of those 43 games were against part timers? How many of those medals were won playing people who'd spent all week in full time jobs and only training a couple of evenings a week? As for keeping his place , well the Ego situation at Wigan was well known and you had to have some balance hence the Cassidy's McGinty's, Panapa's and Edward's of this world. Shaun was lucky , he started young and if you like timed his time at Wigan to pretty much perfection.

I see you havent commnted on the other stuff

Forced out my ar$e , he left of his own free will and judgement and Wigan at the time (being in financial ruin) were probably glad to see the back of his salary

Oh is this true btw?

"Edwards was very critical of Australian Test star Brett Kenny. He accused him of throwing a game against St Helens in 1985 after the Cup victory over Hull F.C.."

The same bitter / jealous Saints fans who, in the main, appear to have no problem with Offiah or Hanley featuring?

Edwards was a great support player and fit in well with that team at the time. But put Danny McGuire in that team, and he'd have had similar success.

As well you know, 'decorations' aren't always a reflection on the quality of the player.

If you feel it is, then you must be in no doubt that Wellens was far superior to Radlinski. He's far more 'decorated', that's for sure.

Personally, I think Clive Sullivan is the best candidate

Edwards is only the defence coach for wales. Gatland has probably been far more influential in their somewhat limited successes. Whether or not you want a statue of him, his involvement in union shouldn't be an issue in my book.