Getting rid of Smith and Ellis weren't bad decisions at the time. Ellis has been gone five years, and has only really looked ok in the last 2. He wouldn't have got near the team in the intervening years.

I'm a bit surprised that Charnock hasn't been used a bit more though, he hasn't looked out of place when he has been used this year and Roby has looked like he should have been spelled a bit more during games.

I disagree about Matty Smith mate. We'd been crying out for a scrum half since Longy left. Eastmond was injury prone, Gaskell was carted off, Lomax isn't/wasn't a half back etc etc

Ellis May have played for the club if he'd have stayed on the straight and narrow..
Smith chose to leave due to Kyle Eastmond which then backfired on us.
Both were the correct decisions at the time

I wouldn't be surprised if he ended up at Warrington next season.

Linked with Godinet again. Not quite Farrah...