Depends how good they are and the nature of their crime?

He needs to worry about Leeds instead of trying to control other Clubs, all a bit embarrassing to be honest.

Does GH harbour an ongoing grudge against the Catalans Dragons club?

Regards,
Greg Bird.

Im firmly in the camp of NRL loss is our gain and we need players with the obvious talents Carney has in our competition desperately and he is in his prime to boot.Others have come over with tarnished reps and done well here with no problem.Joel Monaghan immediately springs to mind, im sure the Wolves fans were happy their CEO took a punt there.

Rugby league is a family game for local people theres nothing for him here.

We can never have too many players who can p1$$ in their own mouth. It's something we just don't coach often enough at junior level in our game.

Is France really the best place for him to go though? When he asks a simple question and someone responds "Oui Oui" he might think they're taking the mick out of him.

Wasn't the issue with Bird that he couldn't get a UK visa but could for France? Perhaps the same is true for Carney and GH is suggesting an unfair advantage.

Yes, that was the issue with Bird, and GH correctly got nowhere with it. It probably is a bit of an unfair advantage for Catalans, but if you sign up for an international competition (which the Super League just about is) you have to expect that teams within that competition can employ players according to the laws of their country, not yours.

I don't see English clubs picking and choosing who can play for Porto in the Champions League because their young South Americans wouldn't get a UK working visa.

If Carney had a ban from the sport that would be a different matter, but as an immigration issue GH has absolutely no right to interfere.

As a RU man I am sure you have got unto some strange rituals on tour!!

The point is Carney has been sacked by how many Clubs and had how many issues he is a serial offender!
Add in the fact the Giants had an agreement to sign him but were denied by Visa issues then why should Catalan be allowed to sign him?
SL is not Football on any level so the comparison is irellevant if a player is not eligable for ALL teams in this comp then he shouldn't be for one!
Whether it will prevent him signing or not is another matter but its a fair point to raise no matter how good a player he is.
Also comparisons with players already here is irrelevant they are obviously eligible for all teams once they have served their respective bans etc.

Just to add I do hope GH is putting 100% into the end of season inquest after a p!$$ poor 2nd half to the regular SL rounds culminating in a deserved early play off exit.
These are much bigger issues than whether or not a serial sh## head should be allowed to play for the French when he isn't eligible for the rest of the SL.

But he isn't ineligible for all teams

You do know that ineligible and not eligible have two different meanings dependent on the context of the sentence?

True. Stuff like that doesn't bother me. Drink driving, yes, pee pee fun, pretending to shag a dog - really not.
One of my clubs (where Owen Farrell used to play) had a blown up picture of a bloke's bell end with 100 ten franc coins up his foreskin. Those were the days when special skills like that were celebrated.

GH's public pontifications on the availability of serial miscreants in Super League is a masterful distraction technique, particularly when full on support for one serial miscreant is hypocritically followed up so quickly by moral outrage directed towards another.

With a bit of luck, the majority of single celled organisms who worship at his altar won't notice the season was terminated prematurely by whipping boy SL rabble last week as season tickets head towards that holy grail of 10,000 by December.

Leeds will be lucky to hit 7,000 after this season's debacle in the league - although the sell has started with GH's positive assessment of the season and the coaching set up.

The point is he is admissable to work in France under French law. The RFL is not in a position to start interfering with that (and I've no doubt that it would get it's backside slapped if it ever tried to). There are probably other factors that make Catalans either more or less attractive than UK-based clubs - exchange rates or tax systems for example.

Just a point, but why would they attempt to sign for UK Clubs and then only sign for Catalan when it falls through?

Dodgy ground their mate and I am not going to name a great player who played for Wigan born in Leeds.poor post luv

If Catalan shouldn't be allowed to sign for Catalan because 'it isn't fair', then I fully expect all UK based clubs will terminate their commercial partnerships with alcohol and gambling companies with immediate effect.

You know, to be fair and all that.

err WHAT!?

Did you say [ipositive[/i assesment?

GH at his spin doctor best.

Reality is as it stands theres just nothing to get excited about for the 2015 season. Same coach, same players plodding along. Looking at the last 2 seasons as a whole it's become obvious the golden generation is winding down now, they've reached their zenith. With no big changes in playing or coaching staff it will be more of the same, just worse.

I'm sure both Catalans would be most displeased

Fans buy tickets after a few seasons of success - glory hunters
Fans buy tickets after getting knocked out of the play offs early - single celled organisms
Fans don't buy tickets - game on it's blah blah, no really, by plenty etc.


If you're going to make trolling the internet your life's work then at least have some consistency eh



As a single celled organism who already has his season ticket sorted for next year i'm looking forward to it with the same optimism i've had for the last 30+ years.
Win or lose, most of us go to watch and enjoy the sport that you claim to be a fan of and if there's 10,000 other like minded fans there then all the better.