Slater needs to watch where his feet are in his on-line defence.

That tackle won't help him much.

Completely wrong.

That "tackle" cannot, and should not be defended by any Rugby League fan, regardless of which club they support.

If that tackle had been on a (name your club) player then the same (name your club) supporters would be in uproar.

And you all know it.

Actually we're all just trying to be really polite to a visitor to our forum.

What we should have done is typed "fook off back to where you came from and don't insult us anymore with your poor trolling attempts", but like I said, we're too polite for that.

Anyway, it was just an australian, whats your problem ?

So are you saying that Smith is gouging Slater? or is it the camera angle and timing of the photo?

My problem is
1) That is a disgraceful incident, which has no place in rugby League

2) I'd say the same regardless of who the player concerned was.

3) I'm not a troll

4) I wonder what the reaction would be on here if it happened to a Leeds player?

I suppose your quote highlighted says everything about your club and society in general today.

I anxiously await your reasoned and objective reply.

You’re really not getting this are you – it’s Billy Slater, anything is justified.

Can clearly see he is grabbing Slaters eyebrows.



Rogues Gallery. Good riddance, please go now.

Didn't someone request ''bit o'biff'' during half time?

Had you of not looked at the pretty pictures, certain you wouldn't of even known bout the incident. Get over it, Billy Slater has.

Lets wait to see what the pre-judicial panel say about it.

When was the incident?

Was it put on report by Ganson?

Have the Australians (or anyone else) cited Smith for the tackle?

Who made 'Rogues' judge, jury and executioner?

I refer you to the learned tvoc's reply just prior to this post

PS - You're trolling.

1) I'm not trolling

2) Can you not speak for yourself?

That "tackle" was disgraceful.

Thank God he off to Rugby Union.

I've not even mentioned his elbow in the "tackle"

Oh but it was on an Australian so it doesn't matter.

Im sure you will be able to raise these issues with him when Wigan sign him in 18 months or so

You're looking at a still of a tackle. You have no idea that the photo is representative of what actually happened.

Do you have any video footage?

Has Smith been cited or does he face sanction?

You have massively over reacted and are another example of a bitter opposition supporter seeking some vicarious satisfaction out of the Aussies beating Leeds players.

Yes, good riddance to Smith. Smith was an English centre in the only team in the country playing two English centres predominantly. So, yes, good riddance. Now, when will that shambles of a club you support produce a decent English threequarter we can all be proud of in an England jersey?

I really hope Leeds United get promoted, then we can get back to real RL supporters on here.

F-

I really hope Wigan Athletic continue to be the most popular dominant sporting force in the village of Wigan.

Now, you said you weren't trolling and wanted a proper discussion on this incident.

Do you have that footage?

You have just relinquished any credibility that you may have been clinging to.

the key word in this post is "any"

No do you?

I was at the game.
Did you go?

What do you think the "footage" would prove that the still doesn't?

what happened next?

No, I am not trying to make a point. I am not suggesting there was anything in the tackle and I am not asking for a player to be removed from the game. I think its' incumbent on the knee jerker doing those things to be able to substantiate them. Can you?



No, I watched in on the telly. Did you go beserk when you saw the "incident" at the game then? If so, did you post anything about it on here? If you did do you have a link? Or did this just come to your attention when you saw that still?

Everything. Do you think the disciplinary panel looks at 1 still or a video of incidents that occurred?

You're not usually this stupid? Whats' up?

How are Hock and Paleaaesina these days?
And I think you'll find my sig says everything about my club today.

You and I have had many sensible discussions over the years, often with differing opinions, but that is not a problem.

When I saw that still photograph it really upset me as an RL fan. IMO there is no place for it in our game.

I don't mind a bit of biff, I quite enjoy it.

As I said if that photograph had been shown with a Leeds player (or Wigan player) as "victim" there would have been uproar.

As for trolling you should know it's not my style.

I am one who has defended the likes of Ryan Bailey in different sites.

We all have our ideas on how the game should be played but eye gouging is no no and for some to dismiss it as it's o.k. it was against an Aussie is frankly abhorrent.

Oh I would have Sinfield in at hooker next week.