The holocaust is serious. Very serious.

Do you think this film portrays the subject matter seriously?

I dont think the film really touches the holocaust. It is more about a jew living under a hidden identity in occupied France.

And do you think it treats that subject matter seriously?

You're forgetting this is a Tarantino film we're on about Gareth, he doesn't do serious.

I know. I think Emma thought she was watching "Schindler's list 2 - revenge of the Jews".

I can help with that.

Anything remotely e-bayable is mine. For definite.

I remember them clearly.

and this blog : [urlhttp://www.guardian.co.uk/film/filmblog/2009/aug/20/inglourious-basterds-tarantino-change-history[/url

Your example of Dylan not changing his spots is not a very good one either given that he caused the biggest outrage in musical history in 1965 when he went electric, since then he's transcended nearly every musical genre going apart from classical opera and hundreds of artists across the spectrum have covered his songs.

I'll give you The Stones though.

You can't have the pig vs woman porn back - I got a good price for that at the back of the Merrion Centre.

Ah hem, no I didn't. I thought it a storyline different to the tragic although typical 'Jews in the second world war' storyline.

That went straight to dvd.

We still have one of your dvds too don't we?

Yes. Most of those are based upon facts and tackle the subject matter seriously.

Still, what the genre needed was a good shoot 'em. Those WWII jews were just so drab, grey and skinny. Quentin makes 'em cool and hip.

Kapow.

You mean like Jingle Bells?

I must confess I've not done the full Dylan discography, just all of his stuff that I have come across was a bit sameish to me, I was just a twinkle in 1965

Does the electric phase not get mentioned in the Dylan household

Hmm, well it can't be woman vs pig if Gary has that....is it "101 glass coffee table specials volume III"?

No, think G1 has that one. Think we have got vol II

So you are saying that some Jews in occupied France didn't hide their identities?

whos got my "Raiders of the lost @rse"?

That'll be me.

Its on the shelf with 'Shaving Ryan's Privates'

Let me get this right.

Tarantino's directed a WWII porno, shot from a Jewish perspective?

No, that is clearly not what I am saying. How on earth have you gleaned that?

I am saying that the film didn't treat the subject matter seriously.

No, the outrage was from his army of pre-65 folk club beatniks in their dufflecoats, beards and sandals, and the blokes dressed pretty much the same way too.

You should visit the famous video review web site and type in something like "bob dylan don't look back" to see the hilarious exerpts from the film documentary of that time, the gigs when Dylan played two halves, one for the traditional folky beatniks and then the second half when the band got out their electric instruments and all hell let loose in the audience.

Wasn't Dylan widely called 'Judas' at the time ?

It wasn't ever advertised as a serious factual film though was it?? In fact before we went to the pictures, Danny told me it was more of a comedy. Whilst the subject matter is serious and certain facts were included, certain aspects of the film were funny.

Brad Pitt isn't really in the film a right lot though to say he's the lead, all the main long scenes like the first scene at the house, pub shoot out and a few others he's not in any of them.

Agree about the Jew Hunter though reckon Christoph Waltz could get an Oscar nomination!