Who won the SInfield dummy spit sweepstakes?

credit where it's due he was supurb. what he needs is to do it on a regular basis. the talent is there,it's up to him

Credit to him though, he didn't hide. He made a couple of howlers in bad weather which were not his usual thing. Scored a good try and did plenty of work. I think on balance he did alright.

Agreed - I still believe that the step up to Super League is a step too far for Hall.

That's a bit much mate.
He made a couple of mistakes but has improved his game no end imo and he proved that at old trafford.

Bailey had two good breaks during play. I hope he is good for next week.

I think Bluey will look at it like that too.

Barrie Mc was dropped for the CC final for the same.

He certainly had a howler, and would also have been held to account if Webster's try had stood, but I'm not going to bin him over one poor game.

It's a very big ask to play in Super League, the potential is there, but for me I'll leave it to the end of the season to see how he develops.

He's definitely going to be on the receiving end of a few high bombs next Sunday

He has only played two!!!!!

Hope Baileys alright he actually had a good game last night.

Bailey - I am not his biggest fan but he did have a really good game last night - I hope he is ok for next week and that he can maintain consistency.

Hall - Better he had a howler last night than next week IMO

Bentham - Total @*&$ - No one has mentioned the Diskin tackle when the HKR player was about to offload but Benthan had decided that he had called held. Sinfield actually said to Bentham "I am allowd to question" - or whatever he said and Bentham wasnt interested.

I had to go to work on sixty minutes so cant comment on anything after that. Did Bentham warn us about the next offside and its a sin binning? He did warn about the backchat - or can he sin bin for the odd thing here and there??

I wonder what the Sea Eagles think based on last nights viewing?

Hall dropped some easy bombs that he should really be collecting even when it was a bit wet he can now expect a lot of them next Sunday i would think.

I not fekkwitted enough to right him off on the performance in one game – I’ve never believed that Hall has the skill set to cut it in the SL at the moment. Another year in the reserves if I had my way – I think he has potential just not quite there yet.

He'll never be more than average, SL perhaps, but average within that standard. Seems to have too many 'rabbit in the headlights' moments.

Just watching the replay on SSX and so far Hall has made 4 howlers and it's only 30 minutes in.

Hall is 21, in his second full season in the first team, he is going to make mistakes

6 months ago similar questions were being asked of lee smith, and the time and patience we showed with him is coming good

i cant see any problems in his game that arent the problems of youth, he could do with maybe a little more sprint training, i think there is a bit of speed left in him, but when he irons those problems out, personally i think he could go very far

He worked his backside off the whole game though and never hid. He's not known for fumbling so I think we give him a chance here. As for wether he's up to SL standard - I think we may have to have an honest assessment of what SL standard is. He's a good club winger at 21. Seems alright to me.

Drop him to the reserves for a few games to 'iron out' his problems – after seeing the replay this morning he’s just not quite there, too many rookie mistakes to be playing at SL level for my liking.

I still think your being harsh mate he was good in the other 2 matches and even last night he kept his head down worked hard and got a decent try.
Keep the faith

Correct! We heard the same old drivel about Burrow and JJB.

I don’t doubt his work rate at all but just lacks the ‘extra’.

As for SL standard, you make a valid point. Maybe I should have said “Leeds” level.

Too inconsistent for me mate

From me you didn't.

sorry if it's been said earlier - i only skim read this thread

As Bluey said, the reason they took so long was purely precautionary. When someone gets knocked out cold they lose the ability to stick an arm out and break their fall so there's theoretically a chance of a spinal injury, and obviously they have no idea until he comes round properly...

Although everyone seems to be doubting hall who would you replace him with then? Smith can't as Webby is still out so who would it be!?!