Well done on a great win you were the only team that played to the whistle, Wigan were moaning all the time to the ref; bad losers always have been always will be, looking forward to seeing you win the cup.

Well done on a great win you were the only team that played to the whistle, Wigan were moaning all the time to the ref; bad losers always have been always will be, looking forward to seeing you win the cup.

I love the theory that Wigan didn't play well

Having just watched the game back I thought they played really well but we were just better on the day

First rule of the internet, if it says FACT at the end of the sentence then you're not even allowed to challenge it - FACT.

At least they had more flags. FACT!

We are not all clowns who cant give credit where it is due......



This was posted not long after the final whistle......

I wasn't going to chime in but I thought I'd have my say...

Wigan were beaten by the better side, Leeds didn't become Super League champs 4 times in 5 years by being mediocre and for all those people who wrote our side off as old, past it, over the hill etc have been shown tonight that when we turn on the engines we will beat anyone. And yes, a couple of decisions went in our favour tonight BUT a couple of decisions went in Wigans favour, lets not forget the CC final last year when the referee gave decisions in Wigans favour that helped them seal what should have been Leeds game... And in a way you are correct by saying Wigan was at 40% tonight, not because Wigan were poor but because Leeds defence kept Tomkins and Charnley at bay for 95% of the game - Wigan are nothing without those 2 players ripping holes in the opposition defence... As per, opposition fans wrote us off, some home fans wrote us off but in typical Leeds fashion we silenced the doubters....

Bring on the cup final, if anyone can win it - we can!

I thought Wigan played very well. Very dangerous with ball in hand, providing a constant threat. Stayed in the game throughout, scored five tries but it could have been ten without some heroic scramble defence from Leeds.

Leeds also played very well. It was a great game to watch.

Wigan did not play well. 60% completion rate won't win many games. That's not taking anything away from Leeds who were SUPERB. But Wigan did not play well.

All this guff about Wigan not playing well is utter crap.....in most sports you can only play as well as the opposition allows you to play, on the day Leeds were by far the better side and deserved their win and had it not been for a few wrong decisions taken the margin of victory would have been greater but that said fair play to Wigan for not giving in and putting the result in doubt until the last few minutes.

"Rat Boy" Tomkins is an excellent player but should stick to his own game instead of trying to run the game on behalf of the ref, sure Leeds had a couple of decisions which went our way but so did Wigan in the 2011 final, sometimes they go for you sometimes they don't but you move on, and as the previous post stated the winning margin was ELEVEN...get in.

completion rate on its own means jack sh*te, you need to look at the reasons why you didn't complete (and it wasn't just down to you "not playing well" as so many fans are claiming) and what you did and/or were allowed to do with the set you did complete.

oh and many super league games are won with completion rates around the 60% mark btw. just like many teams still lose with completion rates of 80/90%

2 Unforced errors in the opening 6 minutes that lead directly to tries. Those 2 were definitely down to us playing badly.
After that, yes, you forced a lot of mistakes and capitalised on them. We forced some errors and did jack all with the possession, Delaney was like a man possessed today, your MOM imo.


Also, credit to Jones Bishop for grounding his try, brilliant catch.

I've no idea what Wigan's completion rate ended as but as it was stated on the BBC to be 65% at half-time I'd be a little surprised if they only completed at 55% in the second.



Leeds weren't superb although they also played very well. They got a few rubs of the green and that probably proved to be the difference over the eighty minutes. Even after the drop goal Leeds were still hanging on by their fingertips at times with fifteen to go. Hardaker was called upon twice to make crucial tackles (bearing in mind his effort on Hock in the first half) he did well to bring down Hughes and did remarkably to prevent Tomkins going over. At the same time Leeds should have finished the Burrow break to seal the game. I thought the ball going right to Hardaker rather than it looping left to Hall would have done the trick but Burrow's delivery didn't match his break.

The ref was poor and Wigan had an off day but if had been Trinity playing them I would have taken that. A great game for the neutral and Leeds deserved the win.

The errors and penalties in the opening 15 minutes were mainly Wigan's own doing and that's pretty much the time when Leeds won the game and Wigan lost it. There was no extra intensity or physicality to cause problems at that point, the Wigan players just made some very basic errors again and again.

After that opening period the game was more like the close contest that some though it would be but Wigan always played like they were desperately chasing the game, even when only trailing by 10 points the players just seemed to think they had to keep the ball alive all the time and there was a real lack of composure.

Leeds on the other hand were clinical when presented with opportunities in the opening quarter of the game. A lot of the tries were nothing exceptional but just sensible, well thought out play that caught Wigan when the defence hadn't really got into the game - when the first try was scored Wigan just made the same mistakes again and gifted field position and Leeds just kept on taking advantage of those gifts. The Wigan players needed some good defensive sets early on to settle down but they failed through their own mistakes and the clinical play from Leeds near the line.

its just a good job the game wasn't on sky.
we'd have only heard phil clarke crying in the background..

Phil Clarke's box of tissues was untouched yesterday.

Leeds won, it says so in the paper, enjoy the final...

As good as tomkins is let's not pretend he is radlinski under the ball

The Tomkins spill was anything but an unforced error, it was forced by an excellent high kick which spiralled away from him toward the touchline. Any full back in the world would have struggled with that.

Lest we forget that two of Wigan's tries came from Jamie Jones-Buchanan coming up with soft one-on-one misses because he was too busy trying to anticipate what was going on behind the play and lost the lead runner.

Far from it. It's his big weakness.

JJB was a statue at times yesterday in the defence and Wigan exploited it perfectly.

I've stated this before. Without a doubt it's his achilles' heel.

I've not read all the comments in the thread but I thought the majority of Wigan fans were great in defeat yesterday. I can't speak for others but my friends, family and myself all left the ground and congratulated loads of Leeds fans, even shook a few hands and wished them luck for the final. Not sure what more we could do? After a bad performance from our boys we only lost by 11 points to a good side, I'm sure we'll kick on from this and if we don't we'll no one else to blame but our selves!

Yep, I had not one problem with any Wigan fans yesterday. All the ones I met were perfectly civil, both before and after the game.

In fact, the only really unsavoury stuff came on the very, VERY overcrowded (and late) train back to Leeds when a couple of Leeds fans decided that a suitcase near the door was worthy of having a fight over. Happily their girlfriends/wives calmed them down by telling them to stop being such daft buggers.