will keith be there or will it just be someone from the club

And in all seriousness I agree and said so yesterday on here in another thread.

rhinoms will confirm.

Anyway will prevuious be taken into consideration like for instance knocking Maher out at Cas and bitch slapping Pryce when he as at Bulls,
I always wondered how Keith got away with those?

Just watched the incidents again, and in the Senior incident, when Senior is chuntering, is it aimed at Wilkin OR at Gilmore becuase it looks like he is looking at Gilmore!!!!

Its funny how a lot of the key incidents have Gilmore at the heart of it isn't it???? He needs a good hiding.

Don't doubt it fella.

Don't think Senior should get a ban, even as a Saints fan Wilkin deserved a slap.

I don't remember the other incident?

I concur mate!!


Although imo it doesn't look as bad as the ones i've seen in the NRL .
If however it is worse than marys then i'd expect a ban and there can be no arguments.

The first one Smith hit him high then followed up with a swinging arm! Bit of a stretch to lay blame at Gilmore's door there.

Funny watching these two up against each other though, clearly can't stand one another

Not only got away with but IIRC for the Pryce slap we got the penalty

And peace and harmony returned

I try not to get involved with the hysterics - I'd take a game like that every week.

Yet on the pen on 79 when Wilkin didn't release Rob, Gilmour is first man in shoving Rob and it is Gilmore who Rob appears to have an issue with.

You and Keef need to go to anger management

Think you're right, there was a photograph in one of the papers on Saturday that made it look like Keith was actually having a go at Gilmour, rather than Wilkin.

On the photo Wilkin is at a different angle to where Keith is looking.

No you needs a personality transplant or in case possibly an implant

Not only that, Pryce was sin binned!!!!

There's something between those two.

Without even considering previous games there was an incident much earlier in the game, when Smith hacked on for McGuire that led to Pryce's sin binning. After Smith had kicked on Gilmour shoves him into the advertising hoardings and they square up then.

Lovely bit of drama within the context of the game their battle.

That previous was eleven years ago so it'd be stretching natural justice to load it up over that distance besides which copping a sin-binning (IIRC?) and receiving a four match ban (that's a definate) is hardly getting away with it.

My guess would be 2 for JJB, 1 for Keef

Wonder what was said to Senior to get him react like that. I am sure he has had plenty of ` sledging ` over the years. It looked like something was said to him by Wilkin that got under his skin. Then all that finger pointing and verbals. Any ideas what words could have caused this reaction from an old pro who has seen it all before.

Fine for kylie and keef, 1 game for jjb.

Clubs confirmation. www.therhinos.co.uk/news/7823.php

Clubs confirmation. www.therhinos.co.uk/news/7823.php

Sounds about right.

I really am not getting it



Why does Paul Cooke get away with a caution for a 'chicken-wing tackle' yet JJB gets brought before the beak.



Not condoning JJB but surely everyone should be treated equally.

Whats the normal grading for players before the disciplinary?

Is grade C usual for a punch? which lets be honest happens every game.

With regards Kylies. Is grade C the normal for an "alledged" high tackle? I have to be honest and say I saw nothing here that is different to a normal match.

The only one I see as facing possible punishment is JJB, for something that the RFL appear keen to get rid from the game. Although they never seem sure if it is a genuine attempt to hurt or just something that is unfortunate as part of the these wrestling techniques. I also cant see why Bailey did not face similar punishment for what was exactly the same tackle in the second half, is it just because it was not highlighted on sky?

The really funny thing about Gilmour and Smith is that they both fight like girls. They have had a few "set-to's" now and the only person that has actually been punched is Sean Long...