Quote ="Lord_Percy"Given that, how do you record the line-up's from 2007 when Diskin was out, such as Millenium Magic? I've got the teamsheet for that game and it states that Kirke was playing at hooker, but I always thought Sinfield covered that role during the games.'"
I'm from the Roy Walker school of 'say what you see.'
My MM pack from 2007 reads:
Kylie Leuluai, Kevin Sinfield, Jamie Thackray
Jamie Jones-Buchanan, Ian Kirke, Gareth Ellis
Extract from the YEP match report: [i"Ali Lauitiiti limped off early on and Ian Kirke – named at hooker, playing in the second-row – and Kylie Leuluai battled through despite head wounds." [/i
Dunemann and Sinfield, Dunemann and Burrow were OK but when it was Dunemann and McGuire they could be either or and often were. I usually waited for the 1st scrum to determine who was the starting SH.
I take the view that keeping unofficial records allows me some latitude. It's only ever a dispute over the split between starting positions, nothing worse than that.
