For me the team picks itself.

Hardaker
Hall
Moon
Watkins
Briscoe
Sinfield
Mcguire
Garbutt
Burrow
JP
Ablett
S.Ward
Cuthbertson

Delaney
Leuleui
Singleton
Keinhorst

I think I'd play Achurch in front of Keinhorst.

I don't think Achurch has done enough nor Keinhorst been bad enough for that to happen tbh mate.

Do we just go old school and pick McGuire and Burrow as 6 & 7 and just have Sinfield as out and out hooker (and just throw Burrow in there so Sinfield can drop back at the end of sets for kicks)

One bench spot up for grabs really but I think Achurch hasn't had enough rugby to edge out Keinhorst.

Hardaker
Briscoe
Watkins
Moon
Hall
McGuire
Burrow
Garbutt
Sinfield
Peacock
Ward
Ablett
Cuthbertson

Leuluai
Singleton
Delaney
Keinhorst (four man forwards bench but if a HB or hooker gets injured we move Keinhorst or Ablett to left centre and move Moon to HB, with Burrow moving up to hooker if it's Sinfield who gets injured.)

Same starting 13 as rhinoms, but I'm going with a bench of:

Singleton
Leuluai
Keinhorst
Achurch

Don't think Delaney deserves to just walk straight back into the side.

Keinhorst offers more versatility, but I just think Achurch offers more quality, and impact. Keinhorst won't let anyone down if he does play.

Hasn't Achurch just walked back into the side himself after injury? A bit contradictory.

Hardaker
Hall
Moon
Watkins
Briscoe
Sinfield
Mcguire
Garbutt
Burrow
JP
Ablett
S.Ward
Cuthbertson

Delaney
Leuleui
Singleton
Keinhorst/Achurch.

Hoping Sinfield stays in the halfs, his kicking game will be a big asset at Wembley

I think we might see a side like the one against Wigan. Sinfield named at stand-off but playing hooker with 6 forwards named and Burrow on the bench.

Hardaker
Briscoe
Watkins
Moon
Hall
Sinfield
McGuire
Garbutt
Cuthbertson
Peacock
Ablett
Ward
Delaney

Burrow
Leuluai
Singleton
Keinhorst

If Delaney is fit he will get the nod.

Trainings going to be buzzing next week and Mac may have his 17 in his mind,but he'll keep em on their toes

Not exactly stacked with back rowers, with the naming of Ablett in the centre, the resting of Cuthbertson and the absence of Delaney and JJB for tonight though, were we? Needs must.

Thought he showed up well enough tonight to deserve to keep his place for next week.

One game vs Hull after a long absence is enough to earn a Cup spot instead of a guy who has just missed the last two but put in strong performances in his last few he played.

1. Hardaker
2.Briscoe
3. Watkins
4. Moon
5.Hall
13.Sinfield
6. Mcguire
8.Lealuai
17.Cuthbertson
10.Peacock
14.Ward
12 Ablett
15.Delaney

Sub's
7. Burrow
19.Singleton
20.Kienhorst
30.Garbutt

Sinfield moves into hooker Mcguire as half Cuthbo as first receiver

1. Hardaker
2. Briscoe
3. Watkins
4. Moon
5. Hall
6. Sinfield
7. McGuire
8. Leuluai
9. Burrow
10. Peacock
11. Ward S
12. Ablett
13. Cuthbertson

14. Keinhorst
15. Garbutt
15. Singleton
17. Achurch / Delaney

From a defensive point of view Ablett would be more at risk than anyone. From an attacking point of view that would be a disaster. But someone at the club really needs to give his backside a kick to sort his defence. Wembley is unforgiving for poor defence.

Keinhorst offers absolute nothing going forward, absolute zero, so for me Achurch would be worth a shot. However, unlike Ablett, Keinhorst has worked very hard in defence last couple of games, and maybe that is a determining factor for this game.

Knowing McDermott it will be Singleton who is most at risk. He had his best game the other week, and was dropped the game after. Last night he was brilliant again, so expect the ridiculous.

However, I actually think Kylie might be luck if he escapes a charge from the disciplinary. Not sure if he has an EGP? So that could be an enforced change.

Cup final amnesty. He, and any would-be transgressors from rovers, are almost certainly ok

I would agree with ALL of this....apart from Kylie getting banned. As clearwing says there will be an amnesty ...especially for a guy with an excellent disciplinary record playing his final season with his last ever chance at featuring at Wembley.

The last of the 17 should be between Keinhorst and say saget the nod over Achurch deservedly, but he too could figure because as you rightly say Singleton does seem to be McDermott's least favourite for some reason.

Rob will start on the bench , team picks itself apart from shoot out between Jmmy and Achurch for the final bench spot

If Delaney's hamstring is ok he deserves his place over Achurch as does Keinhorst and Singleton. I would not be surprised to see Burrow start and share the hooking/half back roles with Sinfield. We have to practice the balance of time for Sinny between organizing at 9 and game managing at 6 ready for the playoffs as key players could be rested after the Saints game. Not sure playing with one halfback for half a game is a good idea.

99% agree. I don't rate keinhorst as anymore than a half decent squad player.

It's inconceivable if not absurd that Achurch would be selected over Delaney, (if declared fit).

Whoever gets picked, McDermott has a nice dilemma to resolve.
I just hope that we don't pick up any crucial injuries in training this week.

Singleton will be in the 17 easily. I tipped him to miss out on the semi final and so it turned out to be but their's a significant difference to him not getting picked because JJB was available filling the Loose Forward role and him potentially not getting picked over BOTH Keinhorst and Achurch.

Think 16 of the 17 are pretty much nailed on if they stay fit and the last spot is a straight fight between Keinhorst and Achurch. The key thing is does he start with Burrow as either a hooker or HB (with Sinfield to hooker) or try naming Cuthbertson there on the team sheet. TBH I'm not sure the Cuthbertson named at hooker thing should be tried at Wembley. We didn't get to see if it works that's well because of the bad conditions at Headingley last week and I don't think a Cup Final is the right time to test it properly. I know having all 3 of Sinfield, Burrow and McGuire on at the start means more defence for our guys in the middle but on this occasion we have a 4 forward bench and a very useful one at that so we can better rotate the big guys as well as them sharing the workload better in attack as we no longer need to just rely on Peacock doing the carrying in the prop department.

I'd just start burrow at hooker.we need sinnys kicking game on the 4/5th tackles