saying jones-bishop was tackled by raynor at the same time he kicked the ball shows what a joke he is.
for me though, saying first thing this morning that injured players should be stretchered off far quicker or made to walk off is a disgrace.
the doctors are the experts, not him. all he was worried about was the image of the game with to many people being stretchered off.
i wonder if he thought that when he was stretcherd of with a serious neck injury.

well done to stevo for getting stuck into him

He's a liability.

If he's that bothered about the image of the game, he should walk off himself.

Considering his drivel is on a similar offensive level to Gray / Keys ....

I didn't watch this mornings game, I cannot beileve he said that Tad.

true mate. he was adamant that the RFl should look into it. the decision should not be the players or the refs. it should be the doctors

Nothing surprises me about this bell #*d . i did chuckle when he was knocking one off in our game though with his "the Bulls are back" and we went on to win from 18 down and playing p!$$.

Everyone knows he is a p!llock but someone, Eddie, Stevo or somebody higher up should pull him to side and have a word.

Compare this idiot to someone like Jon Wells, who gave some really good analysis during matches and also corrected Eddie and Stevo whenever they made one of their many mistakes. I hope he is used more often, and not just this one occasion.

I do not want to think about Eddie or Stevo hanging out the back of anything, thank you very much.

Yep, Jon Wells & Brian Carney are the best by a country mile on there.

Phil Clarke's role is to wind up ts.

He's clearly doing a good job.

Teach him all he know's did you Jeff?

He's rather bland is old Philip

Jon Wells, Brian Carney and Barrie Mcdermott should all be used on a regular basis

Phil Clarke, Bill Arther and Terry O'conner are all pants

Bill Arthur creaming over Clinton Schifcofske was the lowlight for me.

Best line I've heard from Barrie Mac...

Championship Playoffs last year.. possibly a Halifax match. One player made a few knock-ons in quick succession and he came out with something along the lines of 'think he should go round the back and have a word with himself!'



Brilliant!

Quite.

A 35 year old whose last game in the NRL was five years ago before spending 4 seasons in Union, yet he was comfortably the best player on show and his performance was the highlight of the whole SL magic weekend.

If ever a highlight could turn SL into a lowlight, 35 year old Schifcofske certainly did!

How sad then that messrs Tandy ,Gee and Mullins can get gigs in yer beloved superior NRL when clearly past it for SL.
S ,Snort ,Guffaw,Burp ,No Really and all the other usual boring puns you were using under yer tired old AP guise!!

Don't forget Jason smith

They all appear to be Australian!

Regards,
Adrian Vowles, Brett Hodgson and Pat Richards (NRL has-beens but all subsequently Men Of Steel).

Thought Cullen was good this weekend too tbh.

Personally I think he's a complete waste of time.

I'd get rid of him, O'connor and Clark.

Clarke was just stupid. All day he was coming out with garbage.

For the clear, textbook definition of the exact situation in which a penalty try was designed to be awarded, Clarke's words were... "Perfectly legitimate tackle...".

Here endth the debate on the legitimacy of his commentary skills.

his predictions for the results were rubbish to

Think Barrie,Terry,Brian and Jon are worth listening to. Clarke is continually looking for the sensational/controversial angle and he just sounds daft.
Clarke's comments re on field medical care were jaw dropping.