Now that was a shocking display!!! Surely in a nation ofnigh on 60 million people the RFL can do better than that!

He was the same for both teams mate and as far as i'm concerned as long as stuart cummings is running things performance's like today will continue.
I think if alibert can get games in super-league then young thewer and leahy should get SL every week.

I did mean for both sides!!!
Utterly clueless IMO.

I though it was a great game of rugby league and that is what I went to watch. Others on here of course go to watch the referees!

I'm sure you did mate i was just re-itterating the fact that's all in case we get any "whino chelping"

I'm sorry Damo but if you thought that was a great game of Rugby League today then gawd knows what you class as a poor one.

Has to be the ones that are one sided like England v France. We all have different taste in how we like a rugby league game though. Apart from the knock on’s it was a perfect match for me. I wouldn’t let silly stuff like that and the referee get in the way of a reasonable good game like this!

And how do you know what my taste is??????

Get yourself back off to la la land pal.

Make your mind up.

I don’t know what your taste is. But I’m assuming its not the same as mine as you did question my taste of the game! Could be wrong but I’m just assuming I’m right.

Back on the topic of referees.

I do hope we adopt the two ref system that they have in Australia at the moment for next years super league otherwise we will just drift further behind the southerners. The stuff both sides got away with today wouldn’t be able to get away with on an international stage IMO.

Quality bit of backtracking that Damo!!!!!

Still was an alright game IMO

Still not sure about the two ref system. One donkey is bad enough. People will always moan about the refs even if there up to scratch. If you were Stuart Cummins what would you change? Please include insight rather then 2d crap please.

I'm sorry but What? He was the same for both teams? what a bag of b0llockss.

Huddersfield came with a game plan, and he allowed them to executue it. Leeds did not have the same game plan.

How many times were Huddersfield on our line? very very little. How many times were Leeds on their line? many many. And never did a single fecking player have not only two feet behind the line, but not one.

He was a disgrace as a ref out there.

From a great game of rugby league to a reasonable good game to an alright game in 3 posts Damo,which means by default that in your next post you will say that it was actually a poor game therefore agreeing with the original post with which you disagred with in the first place!!!!!!!!!1

to be fair the previous times he has reffed us this season he has been good. today he was appalling though and i can't defend him whatsover

Refs, like players, have good games and bad games. Today the whistling Frenchman had shocker in all directions – in fact there were some calls given today that were simply bizarre.

That knock on by us which was let go on the halfway line was fantastic

What about the high tackle on Sinfield on Hudds 10m line? He let that go and they then went and made a break.. luckily Donald showed amazing speed to catch up.

All to often the ref was looking to his TJ to help him out, as if he didn't actually know what to do

The one that got me was the decision to penalise Senior in the first half, when he was being pushed over the try line. I'm assuming it was for playing on after he'd called held, unless anyone knows different?

Also, he kept a very, very skinny 10m. In truth I never noticed if he was doing that when Hudds were attacking, but I'm assuming it was the same for both sides.

He indicated senior had lead with his forearm.

Nah. He gave it for playing the ball after been tackled. Got it wrong like, should have been penalty to Leeds for tackling after the tackle completed, but that was his decision.

That's what I thought as well.

If it was for leading with the forearm, he sure waited a long time before giving the decision, it's not as though he'd play advantage in those circumstances.

Spot on. Im always a bit wary of Terry on the VR duties, but have been a staunch defender of him when he has the whistle, all you can say he was poor for both teams, very,very poor.

He "INDICATED" that senior had lead with the forearm

and i agree we should of got the penalty because he'd called held and the giants tacklers were still trying to put him into touch.