Sir Kev.

Sir Kev by plenty

Botica was definitely on a par with Sir Kev and they are both the best goal kickers the modern era have seen in this country IMO

El Masri and Halligan are the best that i have seen from the Aussie comp

Top Notch goal kickers are priceless and they can be the difference between winning games and even trophies
I recall that the Aussies once picked a very ordinary player called Ross Conlon but who was a great goal kicker for the first test in 1984 against GB at the SCG
He also got picked for NSW that year too if i recall correctly?
I think St Helens signed him on a cameo role shortly after

Zac Hardaker - natural successor to Sir Kev. Aside from being a fine place kicker he was a born leader, humble, all the attributes we needed to take the club forward...

Adam Reynold is the best kicker ever by percentage converted over his career so far I believe, kicking around 85% (this was his percentage after 3 full years in the NRL, I actually don't know his current conversion rate)

Yet, in a pressure situation I would still take Sinfield over anyone, the only last minute kick I can recall him missing was at the first magic weekend, which we all know was organiseed with tansy and intended to hit the crossbar so we could win and not draw the game