i wouldnt rule either of them out i think its best to have to young players competing for the job then you can take the best one

i think both have the skills but gibson loks like he will fill out more if he was to put more gym time in but then again watkins has the pace on gibson

Get rid, he's a turnstile with limited latteral movement,.

I'll forgive you the 1% this time.



Godden was excellent, I don't see Gibson remotely in the same class in either defence or attack although I see why (in stature) you might wish to make a comparison.

Watkins needs to find some composure and consistency to match his undoubted speed and overall potential. When that will arrive is the only question for me. Hopefully by the time Senior calls it a day, whenever that comes to pass.

Watkins is a natural left centre and will be our replacement for Keith. As much as I like Gibson, I think the recruitment of an out and out right centre is essential, and if Gibson has to make way for that, then I wouldn't be too sorry to see it. If we can keep him as backup to Shenton (or whoever, sorry Cas fans) then great.

No Coady is seniors replacement! If all goes well.

Any chance we can wait and see how he performs at Super League level first before handing him a legends number 4 shirt?