Skill wise you are right but at least he has 2 good legs!

Unfortunatley young top notch scrum halfs, that are willing to sign for a team not challenging for trophies are as a rare as hens teeth and would cost money we cant afford. rangi was a gem of a find but unfortunatley those are quite rare.

Rangi chase was all down to adrian vowles.
Maybe adrian can keep a look out for another young half back over in oz.

sherwin is well past his best...even at the dogs his game was erratic and full of injury's towards the end.....dont forget he was playing behind a pack which included mason,o'meley,grimaldi,ryan and he still struggled at times.......... if a half-back cannot perform with them infront of you then he never will...

And Sonny Bill Williams.

I think it's pretty obvious we'll need to replace Sherwin at the end of this year due to his age and injuries (though nothing would surprise me). Therefore, it's perfectly reasonable to have a discussion on who might replace him as scrum-half. I'd love Brierly to come in and 'do a Tompkins' but we have to be realistic in that you'd be asking a teenager to take on a pivotal role in the team without any back-up, which is a gamble if you ask me.

I would like to see an experienced SH, along the lines of Brett Finch, who's remit would also be to mentor Brierley and bring him through for the future to link with Rangi. Easy to say, not easy to do though!!

Finch is a solid player,played state of origin etc, and plays behind a good pack of forwards at melbourne.

But as Sherwin found out playing behind a massive pack full of international caps in Oz doesnt mean much when our lot
are losing the forward battle here and we expect him to work miracles behind a pack going backwards.

In my opinion its the hardest position in the side to fill,as the likes of Hull and Bradford have proved,money or age no object.

Andy Lynch. He's nailed on apparently.

As nailed on as Bulls4Champs2010?

















Actually, you're not allowed as many laughing smilies as your username invites...

No, even more than that.

In the short term to add to the tiny squad why not sign Paul Cooke? A bit of a fruit loop but he can play stand off and move rangi to scrum half! And if Sherwin is fit you can rotate using Rangi and hooker to rest Hudson with Cooke and Sherwin in halfs or stick him at loose if westy needs a break.

I can't see him being at HKR much longer!

And according to a poster on the V.T, Wakey lead the chase for Finch for next year.

yep its true, Cookie and Finch both wakey bound

Guess that settles whether brough is staying or not.

Doesn't help us though!

yep its a shame for us, HKR think they are nailed on to get him but i've been told a 4 year deal is waiting for him at Giants when his contract is up with us

Huddersfield have just given Robinson another deal. Both he and Brough are specialist scrum halves so can't see both of them in the same team, I heard Brough had very high demands.
Hull KR are also said to be interested but again they have Dobson who is very much a 7, couldn't see them playing together either.
I've also been told Brough is going to Warrington but after paying £200k for Myler to play 7 I can't see that either!I think it's a case of wild speculation, probably put around by his agent to get him a good deal wherever he goes next, or even to stay at Wakefield. It has to be said that most 'top' teams have a scrum half signed for 2011 and it wouldn't surprise me to see him stay where he is for another year or two.

If KR get Brough, I want Dobson! He always murders us!

Robbo is most effective when playing like a 9. Lacks the skillset for a top 7. So you could have someone - Brough / Finch ?- at 7 and play Robbo as the interchange 9 with Lunt.

If we try to sign Dobson, Wigan will only jump in and get him. Then we will get relegated. Ohno. That already happened!!

As i recall we couldnt sign him because he hadnt played enough senior games in aus, then a few days later the ruling was changed to include his games in france just before wigan signed him. Call me a cynic but i always thought the two may have been linked.

As i recall we couldnt sign him because he hadnt played enough senior games in aus, then a few days later the ruling was changed to include his games in france just before wigan signed him. Call me a cynic but i always thought the two may have been linked.'"

Hudds are in talks with Brough news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/rugby_l ... 568233.stm So it looks like they will have at least 2 scrum halfs better than ours next season unless we get someone fast!

Hudds are in talks with Brough news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/rugby_l ... 568233.stm So it looks like they will have at least 2 scrum halfs better than ours next season unless we get someone fast!