Told you he was good (waltontiger

)

I don't know whether he is as good as Westerman only time will tell, but I think I'm vindicated in making a fuss about him



Whatever, we are both producing talent

Nobody ever said he wasnt a talent, The thing is Joe has Class, Pure skill

I remember playing against Dale as a youth and he has progressed well, But he will never be a superstar, He will be very solid, Runs and Tackles hard but not got that x factor joe has, IMO

Luckily for us all you are a woefull judge of talent, personally I can't split them though they are very different players. Not a superstar - try telling John Kear that





PS: I'm consistently amazed by the players you claim to have played with/against - are you superman

Dale had a good game but me and my lad were ing ourselves laughing at his pi key little ponytail.

Yeah I wish he would get rid of that.



If he can stay injury free he will have a big year for us

Well done on beating 3 sides that haven't got a point this season yet



I'd rather have Shenny than Westy myself but they're both class acts.

Blooming heck, the saga continues

IMO Bibby will make a better player than Fergy but Westerman is at the moment better than both. Wonder what it would be like all 3 plus Pitts, Ferres , Shenny, Owen and Boyle all in the same team.

Fergurson has been the buy of the century for my fantasy team. Dixon is another. Pretty cheap but scoring plenty of points.

Forgetting young Dale for a second, which crackpot at Bradford agreed to let Halley go out on loan for another month?

He's scored more tries on his own than the whole Bradford team have so far this season.

Deary me today.

I watched him go over last night, looked at my other half and we both said together: "That'll be Vasty putting a thread up then!"...

To be honest, i was shocked that Bradford let him go in the first place, fair enough giving the lad experience but imo he could walk in to just about any team. He is an awesome player

Aye

NO! It would be Calder RLFC!!!!

You mean Bibb I take it - and no he is not as good as Fergy and any Wakey fan will tell you. To quote Detoriman Fergy has an X factor in that he pops up when it matters. That said Luke George who know one has mentioned has the real knack for stealing the show, Was not a winning try like he managed against Leeds but still very flashy for a guy just on after a 12 month lay off.

George is my tip for stardom, there I've cursed him now dooh

Westerman has a season head start on Fergy so I'd agree he isn't as good yet. As I keep saying it's not where they are now but where they will both be when they are 25-26, then you will know if one, both or none of them made it. That's my big issue with overhyped young players not just Westerman, you hand out the accolades at the end of thier careers not the begining. That's the difference between us and the Aussies they have a healthy respect for players who learn their trade.

I can personally state that Dettoriman has played (and been smashed by):-

Ryan Boyle
Kyle Bibb
Dale Ferguson
Tom Burton - Hudds
Scott Glassell - Hudds

and Sean Johnson during training

Bloody hell i could smash dettoriman

How weak and small is dettori man to be smashed by this guy.

Who's Ferguson?

Does he play for Cas?

Shouldn't this be marked O/T?

=red-edit-
It has now. Thanks mods.


-edit-
One swallow does not make a Summer. It doesn't even make a drink. I don't think we should be over-hyping unproven young players. Tell me, will he ever be as good as the great Mal Reilly?

We can only say if he's good or not when he's won the World Cup Final single-handedly.

Bah! Humbug!

I thought all the poison from Hicksons had been cleared away!

He probably won't be as good as Mrs Reilly, we don't make em like that anymore.

To be honest I hope I speak for a lot of people here, but who gives a sh*te who is better. They are both young English Super League players.

Let's be honest, if Dale turns out to be any good in the next year or so i'm sure Terry will snap him up to help cover Westy.

Joking aside the progression of players like Westerman and Ferguson is very good news for the future of GB/England.

How soon they'll get a look in ahead of the usual tried, tested and failed suspects is another matter.

It's not poison, it's more of a medicine.

Think of it as some sort of diuretic...

Correct, But at least i tried - And your Sean never carried me 50 yards to score, Like he did with 2 players on his back, And he didnt smash me, He just ran straight through me haha
And you must be lying mate, I make up all these players

Nothing to do with the fact where all the same age