So, looking at [url=https://mobile.twitter.com/RLFansUK/status/329170711203676161/photo/1this[/url it looks like Salford had 14 players on the pitch against you guys for a bit the other night. What do you guys think of this, would you have won if they didn't cheat? Not trolling btw just never watched the game so not sure if you had any chance of stealing it at the end.

yep it was whilst we were camped on their line in the last 3 minutes.

The RFL wouldn't want to upset their new loaded owner too much...so a slap on the wrist or a small fine.

Complete joke.

I think a rematch is in order!

The cherry on top of a completely incompetent performance from the match officials. Clearly we do need referees though - the farce that was this game, wasn't far short of an experiment in not having them at all.

Well considering Mr Tansey shouldn't have been on the field perhaps we were just taking the man advantage that we should have had in the first place!

In all seriousness surely the fourth official has some questions to answer. He is responsible for sending a player on without calling one off.

Just had a look at the game, had it saved, you were done, 14 players defending the line and all stevo and hemmings could say was how well salford were defending their lie, beggers beleaf

It's interesting that had the referee awarded Cas the accidental offside that Salford were guilty of immediately prior to the Tansey tackle, it wouldn't have happened in the first place.

It was just a bad game to watch, I can't believe how much the officials got it wrong in that game for both sides. The drop out as well (when you had 2 players not even behind the line) that made you go up the field with our 14 players.If anything punishment should be at the French plonker and his assistants

Oooh my favourite game. Spot the Flanker!

or maybe going the aussie way (could be a wrong though twice as many mistakes) but ithink it is coming the players are cheating more and more in the game time to sort it out Rugby League get off your backsides and do some work for your wages or resign then we can get someone in who understands the needs of rugby league you are a joke at the moment.




0

What have the Cas fans done to deserve that

Was Halibut the ref? we all know he can't count

Just seen it was Halibut



Surely the RFL will now do something about him

To be fair to Alibert when was he supposed to have the time to count the players? It is up to the other officials to keep check of who is going on & coming off, for once Alibert can't really be blamed.

I'm not condoning The 14 man gag, but how long time wise was this for, and how many tackles were committed by Cas in that time?

Nobby cheating Cas again! Salford should be penalised two points at least, otherwise we"ll see this again when a team are defending a slim lead and are under pressure with the clock running down.

Why is anyone surprised. Last year Halibut lost us a game because he couldn't count to six and gave the Wire an extra tackle which led to a win. So counting to 14 must be well beyond him and his buddies.

He could! he went past six to get to seven or "sept" as i think it is in his native lingo


Point taken though he is a prat, a very arrogant prat at that.

I think the worry for all concerned is if the RFL just give a slap on the wrist to Salford or a small fine.

If any side were holding on to a lead which could affect an important cup tie or play off place would they gamble on trying the same thing deliberately if the financial rewards outweigh a potential fine?

But you really can't see a points deduction or every team would be searching the archives for some such misdemeanour.

I didnt watch the game so i don't understand wether or not it was likely to have affected the final outcome.
But this is another catastrophe during a Halibut refereed game.
Some action must be taken by the RFL against the referee and salford, what that should be i am undecided.
My main consern is that clubs are not allowed to make this a bad habit like the water carrier or physio that spends half the game on the pitch coaching.
Give some clubs an inch...

I'm a reds fan and if true we should lose the points especially as it was when you were camped on our line. Personnel change but professionalism remains the same.

Salford had 14 men on the field for 3 of Castleford's plays at the Salford line according to our complaint to the RFL.

I can not believe how inept the running of our sport is.

Can you imagine a football team having twelve players on for the last few minutes?

Actually, this happened in football in an FA cup tie I believe between Fulham and Southampton.

one team had a man sent off, and a sub came on in his place. The team won, but were later removed from the cup and the other team re-instated.

Although you cannot compare sports, and taking into account my bias, I believe the points should either be shared or awarded to Cas.

Whether intentional or not, this was indeed cheating and the game void