Saw this on another thread thought it'd Just be abit of fun. But who do you think the worst player is to pull on a Black & Amber shirt?

I'de probably reckon Craig Greenhill or Tom Harberecht

That big fat pig what spilled his beer all down me back at Cas this season

Oh these threads are always fun...

Do I get a prize for being the first to mention Andrew Johns' best mate Sean Rudder?

He obviously knew who you were then!



Back to the thread though, it has to be a choice from Craig Greenhill, Tom Habrecht, Peter Coyne, Matthew Whittaker, Luke Dyer... We've actually had more than our fair share of these.

Coyne all the way for me. But Van Der Velde, stuck with him and defended him to the hilt.

surely I can't be the only one who thinks Ryan Clayon's gotta be a contender...

Ryan Clayton by a country mile.

Seriously? By a country mile? You obviously blinked and missed Paul Franze's 'contribution' a few years back

Adrian Flynn or Ian Bragger for me, both as bad as each other as far as i remember.

Looking at some of them names above.

By heck we've signed some donkey's.

The obvious choice: SEAN RUDDER

Fiona, that Sione bloke.....whatever his name was, utter spineless tool given too many chances by TM before we got rid!!!!!!!!!

In my limited historical knowledge, I would go Rudder, but then again, I would like to be as "crap" as him and had his career! Bad timing for us I think.

Matt Whitaker in the recent past seemed to have least natural talent, though then again, he has made a career playing the game - I aint! Then again from the stands I never missed a tackle or dropped a ball!

And an honourable mention to Paul Newlove - this was one of those occasions where every single person knew he was well past it and wouldn't make a serious contribution and we were all right, though he was class before he rolled up at Cas - that said, that's most people's first negative reaction that whoever we sign, so it was going to be proved right sometime!

Ryan Sheridan

Sean McVean

That's the name that sprung to mind for me... well the name didn't so much as spring to mind as the recollection of a player who had 3 appearances and look well out of his depth. The name took a bit of thinking of.

Me too! I still remember the 92 semi final, where he ran 90 metres and then as he got tackled, he 'passed' the ball back 50 metres!

BALLANTYNE what a donkey, even when donkeys were in fashion

Not as many as Wakey, we had six pages of them

Damien Reid
Paul Franze
Paul Newlove
Luke Dyer
Sean Rudder
Ryan Sheridan
Keith Mason
Matthew Whitaker
Ryan Clayton
Sione Faumuina

Grant Edwards and Kyle Warren

Although Sheridan and Rudder are good shouts

Some of the selections so far suggest we need a clear distinction between worst player (based purely on ability) and worst signing (based on actual performance or what their level of ability/inability cost). Ryan Sheridan, Paul Newlove were bad signings wheras Harbrecht appeared to be a bad player and he gets my vote although there are probably worse who I've forgotten.

Tim Spears?

Dwayne Barker(how is he these days anyway?) Matt whittaker (the big strong second row who knows his way to the try line

) Gray Vianne and the loveable Frank Watene are ones from recent memory

Rudder and "chuckles" Greenhill