Blacks passing was poor, however i feel a bit sorry for him because he can barely walk half the time! He should not be playing because of his injury. Anyway there are plenty of other people accountable for the defeat.

I feel sorry for Royston, Patterson and Goddard today who all put in half decent performances

the team, Gene had trouble with his knee. Black was half fit and spent most the game Defending out on the wing..

the forwards only take the ball up maybe 2 tackles out of the 6 at the most.

we didnt have enough in the forwards, half fit backs, Penky sinbinned deserved not suprised he was angry though playing like that today.

Where was Bowman? not even selected.

we missed Brannighan we really did.

He was ill.

Didnt stop him from being out on the raz last night if the rumours are true.

Blacks passing this season has been awful, too high, too low, behind the man, its a basic skill.

the problem is with our playmakers, they all think they have to spin the ball at 300mph into someones stomach and those passes come off maybe 1 or 2 out of 20, we can pass the ball soft as well.

we pass the ball when the players are close to collision as well, so as soon as they get the ball there in the tackle.

sure i saw him out on thursday night aswell, in acca, maybe thats why he's ill

although we had little to offer in attack the sort aspect for me is the defence, or lack of it. 42 put past us by a 12 man championship 1 side and 48 today. It beggars belief. Oh and where has the team spirit gone? They even entered the field to "fax on fire" hah

To be honest i felt that playing that song as we waited to kick off was a bit cheesy and conceited, not on the scale of the country mile comment but in the same area, plus to then get hammered makes it even worse. Maybe before the game yes pre entertainment but not when the players are on the pitch kicking off, made me slightly cringe.

Should be no need for Spin passing unless missing players out-which is rare. What happened to the 6 o´clock pass that are the basics of passing?

Just heard Calland on the Radio and saying certain players are "in last Chance saloon". Well Matt you wanted then here and signed them on 2 year contracts. So them words are for me meaningless. Are we going to sell them? Who to?Are we going to release them? Again thats just wasting money! We have the option of loan players-but whilst every other team gets them we dont bother! Matt look at the source of the problem-Coaching, attitude and discipline on and off the field! not just say players are in last chance saloon.

was not very impressed by leigh, yes they did basics right and not many errors, but to me they were a very ordinary side.
which makes fax worse than ever.

Some of the PLAYERS are in Last Chance Saloon!

I think Matt Calland has had a permanent table reservation for some time now and the time has come for him to settle his bill and do the honourable thing.

I thought so also, they were just enthused over a poor team. I can't believe it took them half an hour to score, it should have been way more than 48.

Is that not the problem, Bowman , who else ?

Is History repeating ?

Dont fret, we were poo last week and terrific yesterday.

Beswick, Cherryholme and Aizue for me. Bowman is a good player who puts the work in usually.

It took them 30 min to tire our fowards out, then it was easy for them. Except for big Frank our pack looked too old and slow, unable to cover in defence and no punch in attack.
The worrying thing is other than a couple of players the team today was the same as the one that was scoring for fun last year.
Today we had no idea. Our body language before the kick off was poor and got worse through the game. if the players can not be bothered then they can't expect the fans to shell out £15+ to watch them.

And long may Championship sides consider us to be 'very ordinary'!

In 26 years of watching, this was the worst ever home performance that springs to mind. Absolutely souless performance. I feel demoralised and cheated today.

Another whinge: £18 to watch this or any other championship rugby is a joke. Over £40 for a family to watch semi pro RL is unacceptable in times of a recession . You can watch premiership football for less..

What a wasted opportunity. The stand is fantastic, the band were excellent and a decent crowd turned up, but the team looked it just regressed 4 years. We had a real chance here to convince some of the floating fans to turn up against next week - now there's no chance.

Black didn't look fit and Penky simply isn't a half-back - Gene should have played there to tighten things up. There's a real lack of a rugby brain when Branighan isn't playing - the 2 cheap points given at the end of the second half just sum it up really.

I don't think Leigh were particularly brilliant, they just knew what was expected from each of them, were disciplined and had a game plan. Can't doubt the players efforts, but it's like watching headless chickens at the moment.

Time to get someone else in before the season runs away from us. I was looking forward to getting a big team in the cup (assuming we get past Swinton

) - now the thought of a Super League team coming to the Shay is not so palatable.

Stand looks great though

.

The pensioners in your front row were battered off the park which left us in control for the majority of the game, we were the best team by a country mile.

Its down to many factors. Several half fit players out there who are obv not going to give 100% and then some players not putting in enough effort. Too many old men in the team and this is occasionally letting us down with lack of covering tackles e.g Wrench, Larder. Black is atm a total liability he is giving away more tries than he scores so he needs to have time out. Its a shame that we can't play out of form players in the u21s because some need to get some confidence back. Calland is not the man to take Halifax forward for me, the players are not professional enough under his leadership and this is unlikely to change so expect more highs and lows. AIt would be better to get a coach that has his team well drilled like Leigh but who would come in.

A little unfair in my opinion as they didn't need to be anything but ordinary because we didn't pose a challenge to them

Your pack was beaten senseless today and not a high shot in sight.
We softened you up then pulled away, at times I thought some of your forwards were going to throw up on the pitch.
Defence wins games and our defence today was awesome.
We ran at Frank and took his go forward away, Aizue was pooh at HKR, Gene is 106 next birthday - why dont you spend some money on your local kids instead of quick fixes.
Nine of that Leigh team played against you last year btw, what a difference a great coach makes.

Too true Maurice!!

Agreed Maurice with much of that especially the point about the coach.