Got it

Anyway our ground is better than Salford's so why would he want to go there.............................

Locked

You see you're all saying the reason he was poor was because he was playing at #6, thats no excuse to throw a pass that isn't there. Shad Royston wasn't making these razy passes when he was playing at #13.

Just put it this way. Would you want to see Penky playing at 9 in the opposing team? I certainly wouldn't. Penky at 9 buzzes, makes things happen and wins games.

Widnes away last year, Fev away this year just to name two obvious ones. Its clear he can't play 6, hence why people have a bee in their bonnet over him. No one complained about him the year before last when he played all year at 9 and got nominated for the player of the year.

I reall hope Penky does stay, he is our captain and a real driving force behind our team and I feel we will lose a dimension of our side if he goes, just like Holroyd.

Penky has to stay now. Leigh are coming to the shay again. This time its Porky Bibey!

Great news if true! according to reports he's turned down Salford to stay at fax. viewtopic.php? ... 5&start=45

Great news if true! according to reports he's turned down Salford to stay at fax. viewtopic.php? ... 5&start=45

Quote ="Bartsbro"Great news if true! according to reports he's turned down Salford to stay at fax. viewtopic.php? ... 5&start=45'" Lack of ambition from Sunbed boy.

Quote ="Bartsbro"Great news if true! according to reports he's turned down Salford to stay at fax. viewtopic.php? ... 5&start=45'" Lack of ambition from Sunbed boy.

Hope to God he's staying with us.

Salford are a club going nowhere, their place in SL is in jeopardy, their stadium still hasn't been finalised and finished nowhere near the play offs last year.

He'd have more ambition staying at Fax, only way is up for us! He'd even have more ambition going to you lot, although he wouldn't get in the team because of the greatest RL player ever to have lived

Have you seen him recently,not a bit of fat on Rickey,never has been.

Must be great to read back your fellow fans comments who don't rate Penky now that hes staying, I'm sure he was their hero not long ago.

Correct.

www.salfordadvertiser.co.uk/spor ... ague_start near bottom of the page

www.salfordadvertiser.co.uk/spor ... ague_start near bottom of the page

Never been a hero of mine, never rated him.

That's less of a problem when you're already 'there'.


Well, it is a franchised competition.


Finalised? We've been in it for nearly 100 years.


How shameful, in our first season after promotion...


Tell that to Leigh!

Good news if true. No one really considered that he may want to stay at Fax and would probably earn more money working and playing part time with us. Now he can get back to doing what he does best, ripping the division apart from hooker.

Aizuie and Gene will help Penky produce his best ever season in 2010 imo.

Penky's an excellent player who you wouldn't want playing against you!

Have to say I would have patted Penky on the back and would have wished him all the best if he'd have chosen Salford over us. You couldn't have blamed him as it is 2 years before we get into SL and that's two more years of top money he'd have earned.
Still, if he's prepared to hang around a couple of years then that's all the better for us. On his day there is no one in this division better than him. An absolute gamebreaker whose potential has been spotted by SL. Salford won't be the only ones who come knocking I am sure.
Whatever he does this winter he has 90% of the fan's support just so long as he doesn't consider another Championship team.
No one here would want to see him playing against us & that says more than any of the posts, pro or anti Penky!

good news if staying, but article says agreed new deal. he did that a few months ago or is it another new deal.

Whether Penky stays or goes there is no denying that he is a hooker of quality and skill, and like every player has off games. Sadly, he was played out of position far too often in my opinion. But, when he was at 9 he came alive and the go forward of the team went up a gear. Having watched the play-off game against Fev it is hard to understand some of the criticism levied at him; he tackled like a demon, distributed the ball well, ran well out of dummy-half and hardly put a foot wrong. We definitely lost our shape when he was off the field. I'd love him to stay and play at hooker, but would wish him well if he moved on.

Yet again I find myself saying "Am I right? I'm not wrong!". Always said Penky wouldn't sacrifice Halifax for a dump like Salford. He's a quality player, excellent if the story is true and he's staying

[urlhttp://www.halifaxcourier.co.uk/local/Penky-chase-off.5821883.jp[/url

***Fanfare*****

Thank god for that, now lets let him get on with being the best hooker in the league and proving all the doubters wrong!!!!

This is fantastic news! i had confidence he would stop, he is worshiped by most supporters.

Penky is a class act, and with him and Gleese rotating we are unstoppable

THANK YOU PENKY

Especially playing behind Azuie, Gene, Maloney, Said and frank.

Not sure we have heard the last of this.

They may be using this as a tactic to get him to lower his wage demands.

Not sure either.

What was in the Courier only seemed to me to be what has already been on here and the Salford forum. Opinion and/or rumour. No official statement from Penky, Fax or the Reds. Nor any comment from Penky either.

Until something official is announced I'll continue to keep an open mind on this one.

Hope he does stay, though.