Because no professional rugby league player, including Dane Manning, would set foot on the pitch with the deliberate intention of fracturing an opponents skull.

I'm sure he wanted a big hit on him (bearing in mind Sam had been dishing it out earlier), but to say he was going round with the intent of fracturing someone's skull is... inane.

As I've said elsewhere, I hope it's not as serious as being reported and he makes a speedy recovery.

I don't believe for a minute he actually intended to cause the injury he did, but he did. He intended to hit him though and in doing so he must know there is a chance of an injury and in doing it the way he did there was no opportunity or possibility of Barlow defending himself.

Cool. That's all I was trying to say (he wouldn't have intended causing a serious injury). Dane will get the punishment he deserves when it's reviewed.

In the meantime (again), hopefully it's not as serious as feared and Sam makes a speedy recovery.

Agree. As for the rest of the match, it was a good game, hard and aggressive at times, both ways too but nothing that bad. Shame it seems that one incident is overshadowing everything else

One but he did would be enough.
For goodness sake what a stupid post.
Quote
"I don't believe for a minute he actually intended to cause the injury"
"He intended to hit him though and in doing it the way he did etc etc
Isn't the point of a tackle in Rugby League to not only halt play but to hurt someone?
Surely Paul Rowley doesn't say to his players "tackle, but be gentle"
As I say go to bed, chill out and enjoy your game of "touch rugby at school tomorrow"

But you started the "incident"
Read back.

That incident started when Barlow was taken late of the ball. It flared up after that. No hit on Barlow, no incident.

At the end of the day Sam was the best player on the pitch by a mile in the first half, he wasn't put in hospital on purpose don't get me wrong but ball in hand your forwards couldn't get near him.

Hang on a minute, are you saying that no one is allowed to "hit" Sam?
Does Paul Rowley (great coach) say "If Sam gets it start a fight?"

No, tackle whoever has the ball, that happened for most of the game. I'm not sure what exactly you are trying to say or achieve here. I am saying no one doesn't matter for which team should do what happened in that incident. If it was the other way round I would say and have said the same.

Agree, Sam had a great first half, he is a quality player.
Don't want to fall out with my Leyther friends, but to give Sam man of the match "great first half" undermined
the rest of the team who played a full 80 mins.
Good luck Sam

HJ you are talking sheeeite that tonight was cowardly

Come on folk that hit on Sam was awful and the player who did it will have trouble sleeping tonight.

He will be feeling it much more than any of us fans.

Lets hope Sam pulls through.

I will say again you did not see the tackle.


Which thread can I post my 'we need to get rid of KH as soon as possible' comment?

You can't have seen it either because you keep calling it a tackle

Hi Greg, I was sat above the Dug outs and I saw the assault, this game is tough enough without cowards taking freebies

Think I called it a very very late tackle where as you are spouting crap trying to gain some sort of morale high ground but coming off looking like a cock.

I do not get your point, I agree with you but saying if you heard Fax fans mouthing you would kick Shiite out of them ....... Like I say letting yourself down.

Trouble sleeping tonight?
Feeling it more than us?
Come on salfordlad do you think any one who has played Rugby League will think about a tackle they have made?
To be honest, I expected more from you.

Ask him John.

I played and to a reasonable level for 20 years. In my last ever game I asked to substited of because of a tackle I made. It wasn't dirty, it was hard but fair. The opponent had just put a big shot on me in the previous set, so I put a big hit on him. He had an epileptic fit following my tackle. I think about it every day.

I can accept that but that hit has no place in the game we love and if some bellend was clapping a seriously injured player off then the red mist would descend, and yes I would have let myself down but I would have done the same if one of ours had done the same if it was reversed

Our game is hard and is played by brave men, cowards can have a field day but have no place in our game. You had the skill and fitness to win tonight but were let down either by individuals or a gameplan

Not sure about the point

I was replying to gregs post

Were these idiots from Leigh at the Shay match? Yes, stuff like this has no place in the game but Barlow is one of the worst offenders at this kind of "attack". Why is it him that's always at the centre of controversy?