But he is trouble who can be good but also bad and give many penalties away. He also has an attitude problem which is why he has been at many clubs like Hunslet, Fax, Cas, Leeds, Doncaster, Hull....He is also a big gambler/drinker who has had money problems in the past and caused problems in the team due to that. He also has fallen out with many people due to his Ego. Personally I think we should keep away from him.

He fell out with Tony Smith when he was at Leeds as he didnt like how he was being taught to carry the ball

None of the Shudds players are worth a look but a few of the Hull players are.
Realistically only Lee, Thackery, Horne and Thorman may take a step down.All would add to our team any one who thinks different is not quite there.

Disagree as Lee, Horne and Thorman are awful SL players and who add very little. I bet they all would want good money and I feel the players we have are better value and on less money. I do not think Lee is better than Gleeson or Penky. Horne is a utility back but Haley, Goddard, Patts are better IMHO. Thorman is a fullback not a 6 and I would have Miles Greenwood and Shad over Thorman.
Thackray maybe adds something but he is a liability who has a massive ego and is a penalty maschine. He also has a number of off field problems-I would rather not have him.

Luke Branighan and Ben Black will tear the Championship apart next season....

Tony or Thorman to replace Shad if he goes... wouldnt be a bad replacement tbh.

Thorman isn't a fullback. Couldn't catch swine flu.

Thorman only has/had a kicking game and even thats crap now, better players in the pennine league.

Agree - Wouldnt want Thorman anywhere near our team. Not good enough. At halfback next year we should have Brannigan controlling things leaving Blacky to play his natural running game. And Miles is a much better fullback than Thorman.

A few of them would do good jobs in our league. It was only a season or so ago that Tony was playing for the NZ national team..

Horne would be steady away in our league and would add to our pack me thinks!!

Motu Ton's knee's are shot, I was sat next to him and had a great chat at their semi final last season at the Keepmoat. Nice fella.

Fev have already signed one up i believe!!

I have heard Danny Sculphorp could be signing for us

Not as good as Webbo and Thacks.

Wrong

Anyway, I'm always wary of folk who have a player's pic as their avatar. It usually means they're batting for the other side. You're not "Vikingpoof" are yer, Vikingscouse?

ah 'em.

As opposed to the 'animal' rapist Tony Fax like in yours?

Actually, it's not cos Basil was probably the funniest puppet animal in living memory (even funnier than Sweep, Sooty's friend), but Basil is a "tiny fox" ... tony fax .. tiny fox .... geddit? Boom boom!

Would be an ok signing, his Off-loading ability would play a big part next season thats for sure.

Where did you hear this from anyway

Totally disagree

Wot he said

Dosnt matter anyway does it? Webbos leaving as a cost cutting measure isnt he? Heard hes off to the Geordies.

Wrong.



Correct.



Correct.

No where near as good as he was at KR. Thackeray I will let you have.

Totally agree.You going to be biased to your own team.