No comparison between this and last season, won northern rail and only lost 4 league games all year, terrible look with injuries ment we never had 1st choice team on field

Ah yes, judge somebodies support of a club by the number of posts they have made on an internet message board!

Ha, I thought that too!

Out no where near the GF son. were was all your players that jumped about in front of us when you scored that winning try in the rail cup final, bunch of ass wipes wouldnt pay them with monopoly money, you remember your 60 point win and the rail cup, while we organise our day out in Warrington. Ow and you have wasted a 3rd of your salary cap next year on 2 players 1 injured, the other quickly getting found out. ENJOY

Did you not realize it was a school night?

So YOU know exactly how much Halifax's budget is for next season. Or are you just speculating on hearsay

King Feisel told him.

Sue, he clearly believe all the Mark Campbell BS and who would blame him. What Ging Dong doesnt know is that Campbell offered Barlow and Tonka far more than Halifax and they both turned him down.

No unfortunately 'alifax my views come from watching just about every game this year.The hard questions have to be asked eg why we kept loosing to Leigh? .....answer Ridyard and Beswick .

We can only delude ourselves for so long that our "triangle" is working, it has done on occassions but its not consistent . I will accept that forwards provide the platform but behind them its about finding a combination of players that gel . Sometimes it works instantly,sometimes it just doesnt work and its not necessarily anyones fault... that includes coaches and players so I am not knocking people here just being factual.

I will stick with the xmas list request .....2 players please.1 Quality half back and 1 hooker please.......the hard bits are there doesnt look to be too much around and the choice of who will gel together which is entirely in KHs hands.

Don't you just love 'em.

They get to GF and still want a pop at us, Ben Black DG still grates deep......

I think Handforth would make a good 9 for you

Agree he showed quality playing at 9
Against Swinton away.

Sorry, who are you?

funny enough i was going to ask if your ambler lol

Without getting into a ing contest I have only missed 2 games this season, Toulouse away being one of them. I'm not claiming we're brilliant, merely that we are better than last season, and that regardless of who is bought in, I will renew my season ticket next year. Hopefully so will the majority of other fans because that money helps us sign the players we want and need to compete.

You mean like Penky and Aizue, Oh no sorry....Rettie, Handforth, Bracek.....well be right with them

And there's the whole point of the thread. Many like me want to be tempted that I will be watching attractive running rugby with pivots running at the opposition and creating try's.

I admire the loyalty of the statement that you will renew whoever he buys.....good on you ....and presumably whoever he lets go. I think I need reassuring in the type of signing that I won't be watching the same pivots and more one man biff and bash. I want a team that does the hard bits as well as the flash bits .....it's what makes me go and watch......ie entertaining .

Go away....PLEASE.

For no other reason than curiosity, i'd be interested to hear; out of Karl's signings last pre season, who has been good enough,

Craig Ashall
Callum Casey
Ross Divorty
Paul Handforth
Ben Heaton
Sean Hesketh
Dane Manning
Iain Morrison
Mick Nanyn
Wayne Reittie
Adam Robinson
Anthony Thackray
Ste Tyrer

I commented on a few of your signings at the beginning of the season but most on here disagree with me
For what is worth you signed a IM from us we told you he was one of the best in the championship but would be injured more than playing surely KH knew this Regarding RD you have been unlucky with him great signing for you but unfortunate season SH not good enough at Fev or Batley can't understand why he signed him why swap Hanforth for Black that was unbelievable
As I said on another thread you have a very strong championship team and if you want consistency you need to keep the team together add a couple and it's up to your coach to make them better players
Once everyone calmed down you will be back next year in the top 5 whether you win the league or not will depend on your coaches skill to make your players better time will tell

Ashall - started well but has had some real stinkers lately
Casey - seen some good moments but not enough, he's one for the future?
Tiger - ok, workman like HB with little flair
Heaton - hit top form just before his injury, should be good next season
Hesketh - miles of the form of 2010 Batley days
Dane Manning - Absolutely awesome signing
Morro - Good but always injured
Nanyn - unluckiest player ever noone could have thought he would be out for full season
Adam Robinson - Top player
Thacks - ok
Tyrer - class, just needs to be more consistent.

Overall not too bad, be interesting to see how good his pulling power is in attracting Penky's replacement.

You got to realise that there are only really 6 decent teams in this League and based on that you finished mid table. Yeah you got the nrc but to be honest you lost the games that really counted,the difference being DP Is twice the Coach Harrison will ever be. No matter how many odd good games you had,the record books will show you finished below Fev. Enjoy your closed season.

Go gloat on your own board where people might actually give a $hit. Yes you finished above us blah blah blah and many of us have recognised Fev as the benchmark. You must be a sad individual if all you can respond with is an attempt to get a rise??? Jog on flower.

Oh and if I was to bite I'd reply with when it matters versus Fax we seem to have you in our pockets at finals. That must really eat away at you....... Shame.

Nah far from it flower ...you had a couple o good games in an otherwise crap season pal we had a couple o bad ones in a fantastici season,now I know that eats you up .

if were so mediocre why are you bothering posting on here?