Quote ="Kelvin's Ferret"I'm not justifying them, I'm just pointing out the two main ways in which MW is analysed, as it is studies based on some variant of these that people use as evidence to support their ideological position on MW, and to claim alternative position to be myth. Also as I pointed out these studies would control for other factors, but that's just basic methodology, so doesn't really add or detract anything from either position.'"
I am sceptical you can control for other factors. At the moment we seem to be going through a period of increasing casualisation of labour and increasing numbers zero hours contracts. How would you take into account the apparent fact that this seems to be occurring simply because employers can get away with it as opposed to there being any influence on it by the minimum wage? Also give the cuts and recessions in certain parts of the economy e.g. construction I just don't see how it wouldn't be swamped as a factor and in any case many jobs in recession hit areas normally play more than MW anyway.
Quote Yes, but what are these certain levels? It's all a bit abitrary isn't it, albeit no more abitrary than the MW itself? If I'm fit and healthy and have no dependents who is happly to live in a cheap area, then my living wage is going to be different than if I'm a heavy smoker with asthma, who has 10 kids and wants to live in a more expensive area. Also, what about the trade offs people regularly accept i.e. spending more time and money commuting so you can live in a nicer area? It just a bit too flakey for me to take seriously as a standard.'"
It isn't arbitrary at all. It's a product of research not some arbitrary figure plucked out of thin air. Like anything else it isn't going to cater for all circumstances but given it is based on the Minimum Income Standard (MIS) which [idoes[/i try and cater for differences I think it is quite a reasonable concept and figure. In simple terms items have been identified that people need in order to give them a minimum standard of living and those items are costed to derive the hourly rate which is currently £7.45 an hour outside London (MW is £6.19).
You can see the background [url=http://www.crsp.ac.uk/downloads/Living%20Wage/Uprating%20the%20out%20of%20London%20Living%20Wage%20in%202012.pdfhere[/url
The MIS is discussed [url=http://www.minimumincomestandard.orghere[/url
and an overview of what goes into the MIS is given (no Sky TV should satisfy some people)
[url=http://www.minimumincomestandard.org/downloads/publicity/MIS_leaflet_A4.pdfhere[/url
You can calculate if you have enough to live off (according to MIS) [url=http://www.minimumincome.org.ukhere[/url
So the MIS is less arbitrary then a flat rate figure but if you look into those documents you can see how it is used to derive the LW.