Quote ="Dally"This is nonsense.
1.What argument can be made against same sex sibling marriages on the basis of genetic defects in future generations!?'"
I didn't make any such argument so quit with the straw man arguments
Quote 2. Why should gays not be debarred from marriage? Isn't that what the debate is about?'"
If you want to ban a group of people from doing something (i.e get married) then the onus in the person wishing to ban of group from doing something to provide a reason for why that should be the case. The reasons that are cited for why gay people should not be allowed to get married do not stand up to any sort of rational scrutiny. Also another reason why gay people should not be prevented from marriage is that it marriage would make them happy without infringing upon the freedom of others and without requiring the discrimination of others groups.
Quote 3. It is ludicrous to say gays or heterosexuals are attraced purely to their own sex, there are many bi-sexual people. Or are you saying bi-sexual people should not be allowed to marry either as heterosexuals or homosexuals.'"
Once again you resort to a straw man. I never cited this as a reason why I support same sex marriage merely as a reason why same sex marriage is not comparable to marriage between siblings. I'm not sure whether you are incapable of following a simple argument or if you are being deliberately disingenuous but you seem to have trouble properly representing the arguments of those you are responding to ask can be seen from your earlier response to El Barbudo.
Quote As I see it, which ever way anyone dresses up this issue anti- discrmination is not a justification for allowing gay marriage. Such a decision needs to be founded on higher, clearer principles.'"
I've never said anti discrimination is my sole reason for why I support gay marriage. I, like many other supporters of gay marriage have other reasons for supporting gay marriage.
