Quote ="Sal Paradise"Completely disagree - the climatic conditions in Otago or Marlborough are similar to those you would experience between Marsannay and Santenay. They may even be on similar latitudes either side of the equater. There will very few vines in Burgundy over a hundred years old - yields would be uneconomic - also most of the vines were destroyed by phylloxera between 1870 and 1880.
The average alcohol of good Burgundy is 13.5-14% very similar to the levels you see in NZ, in fact 14% is the highest you would expect from red wine. Are you seriously suggesting top Burgundy lacks depth and body I would suggest the opposite if anything NZ lacks real power and body.
If you ask the top pinot growers in NZ what their inspiration is they will all say Burgundy, in fact you will struggle to find a top grower that has not spent at least one harvest in Burgundy hoping to understand what makes its pinot so special.'"
With all the variations in clone choice, cultivation, terroir, climate, vinification, ageing processes etc. NZ Pinot is never going to be Burgundy and vice versa. I would disagree that you would find an average Burgundy at 14%, 13% certainly but the majority of the lower village wines are 12.5% to 13%. Bear in mind also that the climatic conditions in say Otago are different to say Santenay which is four to five times further from the coast compared to Otago.
I don’t think I suggested that burgundy wines lack depth or body they are certainly not as full on as NZ pinot noir, this is universally accepted. I find they (burgs) have more finesse and detectable structure. Probably a fair point is that NZ Pinot Noir is often consumed too young.
I spend 3 to 4 months each year in burgundy (I bought a house there) and through friends and neighbours I spend a great deal of time at various vineyards most recently just after the 2012 harvest with Domaine Vincent Girardin in Santenay. You are right to suggest that growers from NZ visit Burgundy they do, in fact whilst I was there two producers from NZ visited the Domaine including people from Felton Road.
Paraphrasing comments from the winemakers of Felton road they said,
Burgundian wine-makers are largely shaped by tradition, and by the wines of their neighbours. Thus wine-making choices are made that produce these sort of wines. Of course, there is experimentation all the time - at the edges, by "in-comers" and by outward looking producers and over time change the shape & taste of Burgundy.
On the other hand, they believed that New World Pinot - with no traditions to follow - has aspired to produce what the market wants, either directly for the large corporations, or by following the judgement and advice of wine-show judges. They did not express any desire to produce wines like those of the Burgundy region.
I particularly like this book on pinot noir,
[urlhttp://www.burgundy-report.com/autumn-2011/in-search-of-pinot-noir-benjamin-lewin-mw-2011/[/url