Messageboard Home Saturday, August 15, 2020
Latest Articles
rhinoms Superleague ...
rhinoms Superleague ...
rhinoms Superleague ...
rhinoms Superleague ...
rhinoms Superleague ...
Navigation Messageboard
Contact Me
Web Links
Photo Gallery
Game Info
2015 1st Team Game Info
2014 1st Team Game Info
2013 1st Team Game Info
2012 1st Team Game Info
2011 1st Team Game Info
2010 1st Team Game Info
2009 1st Team Game Info
2008 1st Team Game Info
2007 1st Team Game Info
2006 1st Team Game Info
2005 1st Team Game Info
Hall of Fame
Tony Smith ('03-'07)
Barrie McDermott ('96-'06)

Click Here
2013 Sponsors List
2012 Sponsors List
2011 Sponsors List
2010 Sponsors List
2009 Sponsors List
2008 Sponsors List
2007 Sponsors List
2006 Sponsors List
2005 Sponsors List
TheArmChairRef - Saints v. Salford Reds
Posted by southstander on February 10 2012 - 22:20:22

Oi, ref!
by TheArmChairRef

You wait for years for a new columnist and then a load of them come along at once.

Tonight we have the first official comment from TheArmChairRef who gives us his thoughts in tonights performance by Mr Silverwood who took charge of the televised Saints v. Salford Reds game.

What did he think?

Read more here....

All views expressed are those of the author and not necessarily those of the site.

Well my first match to comment upon St Helens v Salford a predictable result but a couple of refereeing areas to comment.

All my comments tonight relate to the tackle area.

I watched the game as a complete neutral but on three seperate occasions were players who were getting up to play the ball miraciously had great difficulty getting to their feet to play the ball. The referee Richard Silverwood was clearly heard on the refs "Mike" heard to shout 'you were diving', this clearly is an attempt on the part of the player in possession to con the referee into giving a penalty and causes great frustration amongst the crowd, his supporters demanding a penalty and opposing supporters calling it cheating.

Surely if the referee is so certain that it is diving by actually calling outthat it is diving should penalise the offending player for ungentlemanly behaviour trying to mislead the referee. It woudl quicky eradicate an increasing problem in our game.

I think in football the ladies game its called "Simulation", I think the day we want diving in our game it's time to give up. Come on officials if you are that sure its a dive, then do the honourable thing penalise the offender and for persistent offenders its yellow card time.

And as an extra for this weeks column,the referee who is stood two metres away from the tackled player at the subdued Langtree Stadium calls "held" at an upright tackle. The player then passes the ball, previously a penalty. The rule changed to allow for circumstances where the tackled player doesnt hear the call !!!

What happens when the referee calls held and a defender holds on, the same outcome isnt available the referee either lets it go or gives a penalty?

We cannot have two rules for the same circumstances, handing the ball back does make us look like a bunch of softies, whatever was wrong with the rule as it stood. Believe me this will be one of the silliest interpretations of the season and wont last, 'Oh I am sorry I shouldn't have passed could I have the ball back please'.

These referees can provide such entertainment !!




Remember Me

Lost Password?
Google Adverts
Member Poll
How will the Rhinos fare in the opening fixtures of the two part season?

Top of the pile

Top Four

Top Eight

Bottom Four

You must login to vote.
All The Latest News
Google Adverts

Whilst every effort is made to ensure that news stories are correct, we cannot be held responsible for errors. However, if you feel any material on this website is copyrighted or incorrect in any way please contact us at so we can remove it or negotiate copyright permission.

RLFANS.COM, the owners of this website, the RLSA (Rugby League Supporters Association) or the 100% League Network are not responsible for the content of its sub-sites, please email the author of this sub-site if you feel you find an article offensive or of a choice nature that you disagree with.

Email RLFANS.COM's owners if further assistance is required.

(C)1999-2015 RLFANS.COM