David Bywaters Player Appraisal - Bulls Away Posted by southstander
on September 04 2007 - 06:22:17
by David Bywater
After a couple of season off, we've once again asked Davidbyw to cast his eye over the Rhinos performances of the weekend and pass numerical judgement on the players.
Bound to be controversial, and to spark debate on the message boards, we'll keep tabs over the season and see if Davids appraisal of player of the season tallies with your Man-of-the-match votes.
Read more here....
Here are Davids thoughts about Sundays away game against Bradford;
Excellent all round performance - stood up in defence and contributed a nice cameo in attack.
Took both his tries very well the only critisism is the inability to stop St Hilaire offloading for the Harris try.
His partnership with Smith looked fragile all night - Evans try was always on the cards - not Clinton's most convincing performance.
One of Keith's best games of the season - fantastic tackling effort which helped to keep the Rhinos in the game in the first half.
Not unlike Toopi - unconvincing in defence - no obvious mistakes but against a faster more potent attacker than Nathan McAvoy Lee could be exposed.
A crucial hand in every try yet again shows Danny's role as chief play maker - he also put in a huge defensive effort - a high quality performance.
Not unexpectedly Rob looked ring rusty especially in defence - ran with purpose without much impact - hopefully he will be running with all guns blazing by the time the play offs come round.
Hero and villan - stupid penalties but an incredible tackling stint - if only he could cut out his brain explosions he could be an asset - I would not start him as he doesn't have the impact with ball in hand.
Missed a number of tackles including the crucial one that led to Lynch's try - struggled against the bigger Bulls forwards.
Not as effective at prop going forward when played in the front row but what a defensive effort - saved three certain trys with one on one tackles.
My MOM - monumental physical effort - a superb offload in the lead up to Donald's first try and a tackling effort than would do justice to any top defender.
Not his best game Gareth looks like a player whose best form of the season is behind him - dropped ball, silly penalties he looks out of sorts at the moment.
Indecisive - got caught in possession on numerous occassions - much better when combined with McGuire - sadly I cannot see that combination returning this season.
In the words of Iggy Pop "The Passenger" cannot have played for more than five minutes - Ali breaks down in almost every game - he should not be playing it is a waste of a place.
Some good some bad - struggled like the rest of the Rhinos forwards to get through the bigger Bulls pack. Lets hope he can keep hold of the ball in the next few games
The only Rhinos prop to force the Bulls back in the collision - much improved defence last night
Very competent in everything he did - the score reflects his limited game time. Hopefully Carl will retain his place for the Hull game
Whilst every effort is made to ensure that news stories are correct, we cannot be held responsible for errors. However, if you feel any material on this website is copyrighted or incorrect in any way please contact us at firstname.lastname@example.org so we can remove it or negotiate copyright permission.
RLFANS.COM, the owners of this website, the RLSA (Rugby League Supporters Association) or the 100% League Network are not responsible for the content of its sub-sites, please email the author of this sub-site if you feel you find an article offensive or of a choice nature that you disagree with.
Email RLFANS.COM's owners email@example.com if further assistance is required.